the_philosopher

HUDDLER
  • Content count

    349
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Community Reputation

359 Kinda Good

About the_philosopher

  • Rank
    NOT NEWB

Profile Information

  • Gender Male
  • Location Tennessee

Recent Profile Visitors


3,042 profile views

the_philosopher's Activity

  1. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Of the 30K Pats fans that will be in BofA tomorrow:   

    It shouldn't be easier to be a Cowboys fan. The Panthers have had 7 playoff wins and 3 first-round byes. Over that time, the Cowboys have only had 2 playoff wins and 1 first-round bye. That's a lot of heartache. 
    • 1
  2. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Can we once and for all retire the name "Philly"?   

    If it bothers him that much, he should probably change his twitter handle.
    • 11
  3. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Is ANYONE able to make a case for Brockel?   

    Yep. Especially when the one that does a lot of things poorly costs more.
    • 0
  4. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Is ANYONE able to make a case for Brockel?   

    Thanks for getting these stats together. Those of us who believe Rivera overly favors vets definitely need to consider them, but here are a few reasons why focusing on rookie starts does not cause me to totally change my mind.
    First,our first round picks have been absolute studs (Cam, Luke, Star, Benjamin), so it's not to Ron's credit that they started every game their rookies years Second, a team that plays a lot of rookies may still have plenty of 2-year and 3-year players not getting enough opportunities to develop. Currently, our best example is Tre Boston who has missed many reps in favor of Roman Harper. Our best example in Ron's tenure was Josh Norman missing out on valuable development in camp, preseason, and games in 2013 (for Drayton Florence and Captain Munerlyn on the outside???) and 2014 (for Antoine Cason???) Third, many of our rookie starts have come in the secondary where it was obvious that the "vets" were under-performing (e.g., Nakamura, Florence, Josh Thomas, Mikell, Godfrey, Cason) some of whom our GM cut mid-season, forcing our coach's hand. Fourth, Rivera often makes comments about the important "leadership" of guys like Cotchery and Harper. I would rather we pay our coaches to coach, let guys like Cam and Luke do the "leading" and then just play the players who have higher ceilings. Fifth, Roman Harper is still our starting safety.
    • 1
  5. the_philosopher added a post in a topic 2015 Training Camp Awards   

    In my opinion, that kind of junk should only last a couple games when the other guys are outmatched. You have to play your potential.
    By the way, I doubt Norman is a new man. I'd say there's a good chance he could blow a game for us this season. But he's too talented relative to the other options to sit on the bench, and he was all those games he was on the bench.
    • 0
  6. the_philosopher added a post in a topic 2015 Training Camp Awards   

    Unless he uses those pronouncements as some sort of bizarre motivational ploy, we really ought to be concerned about his player evaluations more generally. Armanti is MVP, and Roman Harper deserves to start.
    • 0
  7. the_philosopher added a post in a topic 2015 Training Camp Awards   

    I disagree. Harper looked physically outmatched on the field last year. If he starts, it's because of his "veteran leadership," which I do think Rivera puts too much emphasis on. Many of the rookies getting playing time at the end of the year were in because Rivera was forced to by injuries and bad play. But it took too long in my opinion. Let's not forget, for just one example, how long Josh Norman rode the pine because of his "inexperience." We missed out on pretty much all of his team-friendly rookie contract years in order to watch guys like Cason be "experienced."
    • 1
  8. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Kurt Coleman climbing depth chart fast   

    Because he's not Harper.
    • 1
  9. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Pick 1 of these 3 RBs.   

    Just wondering--can we save any money by cutting Tolbert? I like watching him run and dance and all, but I'd rather have a prototypical FB, especially if it translates to savings.
    • 0
  10. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Corey "Philly" Brown's Development   

    I noticed on the first or second play of the game that he made one the quickest moves off the line I've ever seen in a Panthers uniform outside of 89.
    • 2
  11. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Smith to the HOF   

    I agree with this in part. I don't think Steve's stats would have been much higher with a top tier QB during the Jake years because of how locked in to him Jake was. I do, however, think 89 was one of the only receivers in the game who could have caught a lot of that junk Jake was throwing up. Thus the fact that he put up those numbers with Jake is, I think, a sign of his greatness.
    Don't get me wrong; I loved watching Jake play. But he was a weird quarterback. 
    • 0
  12. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Smith to the HOF   

    My money's on 9.
    • 0
  13. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Funchess Learning From Proehl   

    I hate to be that guy, but this seems like a pretty basic thing to be teaching a WR. I'm happy Proehl is here, (because I'm a Panthers fanboy), but this doesn't seem like anything any other NFL WR coach wouldn't be doing.
    • 1
  14. the_philosopher added a post in a topic Defensive Backs Impress at Panthers Practice   

    I was at practice. Harper was beaten badly on that play by Ginn, and Norman saved it. Why not let someone who has more speed get these practice reps?
    • 0
  15. the_philosopher added a post in a topic what's the maddest you've ever been as a panthers fan?   

    How about the night we made Ramsees Barden look like a hall of famer on national tv? I watched that game with non-Panthers fans who had NFL Network. Made me real proud.
    • 2