20 replies to this topic

[osiruz]

Blake Brockermeyer
1-15 season
Jason Peters
Sean Gilbert
Ray Carruth
Tim Biakabutuka
Rashard Anderson
Jeff Lewis
John Kaseys Kick in the SB
the Corner backs in the SB
Stephen Davis in 05

I will add up the votes, 4 get eliminated SO VOTE UP

[carolinanimal]

Blake Brockermeyer. Man, he was overrated. With a temper too. I was only too happy to see him go.

[williamjackson]

The attitude of the players during the 1-15 season. That was the worst on the football field, worse than the individual play of any one player.

Off the field, it's obviously the Rae Carruth and Fred Lane things.

[BigDave227]

Blake Brockermeyer. Man, he was overrated. With a temper too. I was only too happy to see him go.

You are nuts. Blake was never peddled as a Jones or Pace but he was solid in his 4 years here. We even almost franchised him in 1999 rather than let him leave scott free. I would not have been for paying him what the Bears did either but there is no way his name goes on a list above such wonderful draft picks as Rashard Anderson, Jason Peter, or even Rae Carruth.

[stinky1]

how can anyone not realize that its obviously carruth.

out side of oj simpson he might be the worst person to come from the nfl.

[Delhommey.]

Jason Peters
Sean Gilbert
Ray Carruth
Tim Biakabutuka
Rashard Anderson

To me that is the first tier that for some reason or the other were a complete bust.

If Carruth had not been the gangster thug he proved to be, his outcome would have been different as he did have talent as a reciever. Playing Tight End in prison carries a whole new meaning.

[osiruz]

Elimnation rounds

[Insight]

Carruth would have panned out if he had been sane:sad:


I say Sean Gilbert:omfg:
That was Capers' downfall:doh:

[Mr. Belding]

Rae Carruth
Jeff Lewis
Jason Peters
Rashard Anderson

Can't believe no one mentioned Jeff Lewis yet.

[KristenisHot]

Jeff Lewis was my choice.

[catscratch]

you forgot kerry collins

[amcoolio]

Matt Willig has to garner an honorable mention.

[michelle29732]

Chuck Smith

[Veron314]

Lewis was a clown show.

Jason Peters was white trash.

Carruth was just a nut bag.

Gilbert was lazy and fat.

and how do you not have Geogre Seifert on this list?

[HailLarry]

Stephen Davis in 05

Yeah he really deserves to be in there. The man was second in rushing touchdowns in the NFC after coming back from what many considered a career ending injury. I'm sure Pittsburgh fans think Jerome Bettis from 04 was a horrible blight on the franchise. People are so quick to forget what he did for this team.