Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

tarheelfan23

Jake????

81 posts in this topic

he has be serviceable this year to say the least...it just does not look like he has the arm to throw the deep ball this year....like last game if he hits steve in stride its 6, in the GB game he underthrew moose by a lot and resulted in a fumble....i just think that it is time to find our replacement for him soon....

dumbass tarholes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that it's time to get Jake's replacement on the roster, but thats a good topic we can discuss in the offseason.

The best option we have on this team right now at QB is Jake Delhomme. He's an average to above average QB with GREAT leadership skills. He's not going to put up gaudy numbers and he is going to lose you a couple games a year but he can also rally the team and make some good throws.

Jake gives us the best shot at winning the superbowl this year, better than moore or mccown, despite how imperfect he may be. I'm convinced of that. I'm also convinced that if we lose in the playoffs, it will be on Jake's shoulders. The opposing defense will stack the box and prevent us to run and jake will turn the ball over.

Jake's always had a problem with accuracy but if you look around the league...a great deal of QB's do.

Here is the list of NFC playoff poised QB's. I'm not 100% sold on any of them in the playoffs. Jake has proven to be successful in the postseason. Now i'm not saying that I wouldn't mind having romo or mcnabb in the postseason, but I would completely rather have Jake than Jackson, Orton, and the Rookie Ryan.

Romo

Eli

Mcnabb

Garcia

Ryan

Orton

Jackson

Warner

just my opinion though...I don't think anyone should bash tarheelfan23 for bringing up the point that it is time to start thinking about the future of this team at the QB position. The only thing I question is the timing of this thread. The panthers are getting ready for the biggest game this season, we have all offseason to discuss who is the heir to panther qb throne.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since when DID he make that throw? Even before Tommy John he wasn't able to do that. He hasn't ever been the guy to throw the ball on the money every time, he just chucks it up. Plus, Steve prides himself on not getting overthrown.

This is by far the most un-researched, un-appreciative thread for our QB that I've read.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i completely agree with you, what im saying is that how much longer can jakes heart keep winning us games?? i think he can take us back to the super bowl and long as we can run the ball....but how many more yrs can he play??

and fox does not look like the guy to draft a qb and i hate that, he will sign a 27-29 year old vet to get bye...i want to take the chance and maybe get a guy like manning or brady or even matt ryan

I was referencing the jake criticisms regarding his accuracy and the like, not the eventual need to replace him. You're right, we will need a replacement eventually.

But we will also eventually need to replace Moose, and Peppers, and Smith, and Lucas, and Davis, and Gross... but why focus on that? Truth be known, all of our debating and brainstorming has absolutely no effect on what goes on in the front office at BoA. Given our sucess under the current staff, we can rest assured they're taking it into consideration. time will tell.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since when DID he make that throw? Even before Tommy John he wasn't able to do that. He hasn't ever been the guy to throw the ball on the money every time, he just chucks it up. Plus, Steve prides himself on not getting overthrown.

This is by far the most un-researched, un-appreciative thread for our QB that I've read.

wow, get off your high horse.

The guy just questioned the future of the qb position. His thread was hardly bashing the QB. If thats all your gonna add to the discussion, why even respond?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow, get off your high horse.

The guy just questioned the future of the qb position. His thread was hardly bashing the QB. If thats all your gonna add to the discussion, why even respond?

If you mention the fact that one day Jake will retire it's considered "hating" among his minions of jock-sniffers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you mention the fact that one day Jake will retire it's considered "hating" among his minions of jock-sniffers.

it just amazes me that someone can start a thread wanting to debate the future of one of the most important positions on the football field...(all be it not at the most appropriate time)....and people fly off the handle. I don't mind people passionately debating their side as to why the panthers are fine with jake for the next 3-5 years...but the dumba** comments and the STFU's are petty and uncalled for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites