Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

blackandgold10

Stunning Stat

67 posts in this topic

Yea and the Chiefs won the Super Bowl over 30 years ago which means nothing now. Look at teams and what they have done the last 3 years and then you can talk.

Yeah, we only made it to the NFC Championship in ancient history....four years ago. You can't compare that to THREE years ago, which is obviously the cut off point for talking about current relevance.

Using the IR argument is lame. It annoyed me when our fans did it when we lost Jake last year. It annoyed me when we lost just as many as you did in 2004, and it annoys me when people like you do it now.

The team you have is the team you have. Sure, you can say that it helped to contribute to your failures this season, but it's no reason to discount what ANOTHER team has done. The Panthers are 11-4 and already in the playoffs, the Saints aren't. That's just the way it is.

You know, for a team that has been so bad for so long, the Saints have some of the most cocky fans ever. Usually that type of cockiness is reserved for teams that actually have something to show for themselves.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Take away 2 games where the Panthers were playing teams that were resting their starters, in the last three years the Panthers are 0-11 in their last 11 road games against teams that finish the year above .500

I never would have guessed this and makes you realize how important the home field would have been.

unfortunately for you, all you have to do now is look up useless stats. Your team has one more game and then its on to draft talk, and "what free agent can we pick up that will immediately make us superbowl contenders next year"

enjoy the offseason buddy....

p.s. tell Sean Payton to tune into Fox this offseason and get a good luck at the team that will be handing his tail to him for the next 3-5 years

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea and the Chiefs won the Super Bowl over 30 years ago which means nothing now. Look at teams and what they have done the last 3 years and then you can talk.

why is three years the benchmark?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Best thing to do when you enter an debate with a weak argument? Try and establish limits to the argument that only work to your favor.

Team X is making the playoffs like 2 out of ever 3 years! IF YOU ONLY LOOK AT THE PAST 3 YEARS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

why is three years the benchmark?

Ok use whatever bench mark you like. Lets go by the most important fact:

Of the two teams (Saints/Panthers) which one won the NFC South?

Of the two teams (Saints/Panthers) which one last won a playoff game?

The league is about winning and what have you done for me lately. Who cares if you make it to the playoffs as a wild card and then lose. As far as I can tell it has been 3 years since the Panthers won anything and since then the Saints have been the more successful team. I would rather go 9-7 and not make the playoffs then go 11-5, not win the division and then lose your first playoff game. That only gives you a lower draft pick and nothing to show for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Name the 9 starters.

RB Reggie Bush

TE Mark Campbell

DE Charles Grant

DT Brian Young

ILB Mark Simoneau

CB Mike McKenzie

CB Tracy Porter

S Kevin Kaesviharn

K Martin Gramatica

Other significant on IR

RB Aaron Stecker 2nd string RB

Aaron Glenn nickel back

Other significant injuries

Sedrick Ellis Starting Nose tackle missed 4 games

Hollis Thomas DT missed 9 games

Jeramie Shockie: Missed 8 games

Roman Harper (Starter missed 4 games)

Marcus Colsten (Starter missed 6 games)

I could go on and on

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lol, Jeramie Shockie? Marcus Colsten? You really know your team well don't you?

PS of those players out for the year.....MAYBE Mike Mckenzie would be a starter on the Panthers. And I repeat MAYBE. The rest would be on our bench.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok use whatever bench mark you like. Lets go by the most important fact:

Of the two teams (Saints/Panthers) which one won the NFC South?

Of the two teams (Saints/Panthers) which one last won a playoff game?

The league is about winning and what have you done for me lately. Who cares if you make it to the playoffs as a wild card and then lose. As far as I can tell it has been 3 years since the Panthers won anything and since then the Saints have been the more successful team. I would rather go 9-7 and not make the playoffs then go 11-5, not win the division and then lose your first playoff game. That only gives you a lower draft pick and nothing to show for it.

How about which team whipped the other one's ass 30-7, and which one at WORST would finish as the #5 seed in the playoffs and not in last in the division? And who cares what the number is of the draft pick if your personnel selection sucks ass? How many high picks have the Lions and Raiders had recently that have flopped? How has that Robert Meachem pick worked out for you? What about Reggie Bush at #2 with all of the other better running backs available?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites