41 replies to this topic

[eViL jEsTeR]

Falcons, 49ers, Giants, Titans, Dolphins, Steelers = no Panthers.

I don't see the Falcons going. I've got the Panthers as 8-8 or 9-7 at best and missing as well but I don't think the Falcons are any better than us. The Saints will be the only playoff team from our division. The east and north will get the wild cards.

http://www.nfl.com/n...ts&confirm=true

[Smithers]

Falcons may be good enough to get in, but the Steelers will not. They will not win more than 6 games this season.

[Sandy Claws]

Falcons, 49ers, Giants, Titans, Dolphins, Steelers = no Panthers.

I don't see the Falcons going. I've got the Panthers as 8-8 or 9-7 at best and missing as well but I don't think the Falcons are any better than us. The Saints will be the only playoff team from our division. The east and north will get the wild cards.

http://www.nfl.com/n...ts&confirm=true

I'm back








You're wrong about the Panthers

Edited by Savoir Faire, 22 May 2010 - 06:21 AM.

[panthers55]

If the Panthers make the playoffs this year it will be a much bigger surprise than when they did it in 2005 or 2008. Difference is this team has much less veteran leadership and experience. And experience counts for everything in the NFL. All of these guys have talent and athleticism or they wouldn't be here to begin with.

[Mr. Burgundy]

Why is everybody on the giants? What did they do in the off season that makes them so much better this year because they sucked last year

[mr beauxjangles]

I think the Steelers and Giants will both struggle to get to 7-9 or 8-8.

Regardless, what a crappy article. He basically listed 18 teams that he thinks have a shot at the playoffs. Way to go. That must have been tough.

[BF91]

Anything anyone says is just a guess at this point. There hasn't even been a down of football played yet, I'll let what happens on the field make up my mind.

[Zcustom]

Anything anyone says is just a guess at this point. There hasn't even been a down of football played yet, I'll let what happens on the field make up my mind.

but that robs you of the opportunity to act superior to everyone else while dismissing any sensible argument.

[BF91]

but that robs you of the opportunity to act superior to everyone else while dismissing any sensible argument.

Silly me! Obviously I meant that Kirwan is full of poo and has no idea what he's talking about. We have a young, talented team that's sure to make the playoffs this year and set up a Panthers dynasty for years to come! Better?

[monstercat]

Yeah, it's all a guess, but I don't know why it would shock folks to see the Panthers in the play offs though. The only thing this offense will be missing is Moose, and the only real potential problem on defense is depth at DT and maybe in the secondary, but how many other teams won't miss a beat if some of their key starters get hurt?

Let me reiterate that Tank Tyler and Louis Leonard have both been in the league for 4 years, so the Panthers starting D-line is not as screwed as people seem to believe. I don't know why so many fans are acting as if those guys have never played a game in their lives and have no chance to succeed in Meeks defense. It's not like they will be learning from scratch like even the long time veterans were at this time last year.

[BF91]

The only real problem on defense isn't the lack of depth at DT, its the lack of a proven pass rusher. I'm expecting Johnson to post at least 10 sacks and Brown, Norwood, and Hardy should contribute, but having a decent pass rush is far from guaranteed.

[panthers55]

Yeah, it's all a guess, but I don't know why it would shock folks to see the Panthers in the play offs though. The only thing this offense will be missing is Moose, and the only real potential problem on defense is depth at DT and maybe in the secondary, but how many other teams won't miss a beat if some of their key starters get hurt?

Let me reiterate that Tank Tyler and Louis Leonard have both been in the league for 4 years, so the Panthers starting D-line is not as screwed as people seem to believe. I don't know why so many fans are acting as if those guys have never played a game in their lives and have no chance to succeed in Meeks defense. It's not like they will be learning from scratch like even the long time veterans were at this time last year.

Tank Tyler has only started 19 games in his career and only 2 times in the past 2 years. Last year he appeared in 6 games for us and had a grand total of 6 tackles. Louis has started 5 games in those 4 years. Compare that with who they are replacing and it clear that they don't possess 1/10 of the experience that we lost. So yeah they are very inexperienced and very green. Everyone is athletic and talented at this level. What makes the biggest difference is game experience and they don't have much of it. Should we be concerned, only an idiot wouldn't be.

[SorthNarolina]

Silly me! Obviously I meant that Kirwan is full of poo and has no idea what he's talking about. We have a young, talented team that's sure to make the playoffs this year and set up a Panthers dynasty for years to come! Better?

:party:

[SorthNarolina]

Tank Tyler has only started 19 games in his career and only 2 times in the past 2 years. Last year he appeared in 6 games for us and had a grand total of 6 tackles. Louis has started 5 games in those 4 years. Compare that with who they are replacing and it clear that they don't possess 1/10 of the experience that we lost. So yeah they are very inexperienced and very green. Everyone is athletic and talented at this level. What makes the biggest difference is game experience and they don't have much of it. Should we be concerned, only an idiot wouldn't be.

I'm concerned but I'm certainly more optimistic about the situation. I was never impressed with kemo. Lewis was good but not as a starter.

Experience counts when you can actually use it. Off the field I cann see how the cuts hurt us but on the field I don't see some catastrophic lack of experience that will cripple us.

[monstercat]

Tank Tyler has only started 19 games in his career and only 2 times in the past 2 years. Last year he appeared in 6 games for us and had a grand total of 6 tackles. Louis has started 5 games in those 4 years. Compare that with who they are replacing and it clear that they don't possess 1/10 of the experience that we lost. So yeah they are very inexperienced and very green. Everyone is athletic and talented at this level. What makes the biggest difference is game experience and they don't have much of it. Should we be concerned, only an idiot wouldn't be.

So? All Tank Tyler and Louis Leonard have to be is average, because that's what Kemo and Damione Lewis were even with all that experience. Anything they do above average is an instant upgrade.