Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

dixontosanders

Passing up a player, your franchise regretted

32 posts in this topic

Carolina Panthers

Player's Drafted with in 5 pick's (pick's after in parenthesis)

1995- Round 1, Pick 22: DB- Tyrone Poole over DB- Ty Law (1 pick)

1995- Round 6, Pick 191: QB- Jerry Colquitt over RB- Cory Schlesinger (1 pick)

1996- Round 1, Pick 8: RB- Tim Biakabutuka over T- Willie Anderson (2 pick's)

1996- Round 3, Pick 88: DT- J.C. Price over WR- Terrell Owens (1 pick)

1996- Round 4, Pick 106: G- Norberto Garrido over T- Jon Runyan (3 pick's)

1997- Round 1, Pick 27: WR- Rae Carruth over DL- Trevor Pryce (1 pick)

1997- Round 2, Pick 56: FS- Mike Minter over DB- Darren Sharper (4 pick's)

1997- Round 3, Pick 87: LB- Kinnon Tatum over DL/LB- Mike Vrabel (4 pick's)

1998- Round 3, Pick 62: DE- Chuck Wiley over C- Olin Kreutz (2 pick's)

1998- Round 3, Pick 73: DE- Mitch Marrow over RB- Ahman Green (3 pick's)

1999- Round 2, Pick 34: T- Chris Terry over T- Jon Jansen (3 pick's)

1999- Round 6, Pick 175: DE- Robert Daniel over TE- Desmond Clark (4 pick's)

1999- Round 7, Pick 211: S- Tony Booth over WR- Donald Driver (2 pick's)

2000- Round 2, Pick 57: FS- Deon Grant over LB- Marcus Washington (2 pick's)

2000- Round 5, Pick 147: DE- Gillis Wilson over DE- Kabeer Gbaja- Biamila (2 pick's)

2000- Round 6, Pick 182: G- Jeno James over LB- Adalius Thomas (4 pick's)

2002- Round 2, Pick 34: RB- DeShaun Foster over C- Andre Gurode (3 pick's)

2002- Round 4, Pick 100: CB- Dante Wesley over DE- Alex Brown (4 pick's)

2003- Round 2, Pick 50: C- Bruce Nelson over WR- Anquan Boldin (4 pick's)

2003- Round 4, Pick 119: S- Colin Branch over CB- Asante Samuel (1 pick)

2003- Round 5, Pick 145: DT- Kindal Moorehead over P- Mike Scifres (4 pick's)

2004- Round 2, Pick 62: WR- Keary Colbert over DT- Darnell Dockett (2 pick's)

2005- Round 2, Pick 54: RB- Eric Shelton over CB- Justin Miller (3 pick's)

2006- Round 2, Pick 58: CB- Richard Marshall over RB- Maurice Jones-Drew (2 pick's)

2006- Round 4, Pick 121: S- Nate Salley over DE- Elvis Dumervil (5 pick's)

2007- Round 2, Pick 45: WR- Dwayne Jarrett over DE/LB- LaMarr Woodley (1 pick)

2008- Round 1, Pick 13: RB- Jonathan Stewart over CB- Dominique Rogers-Cromartie (3 pick's)

2008- Round 1, Pick 19: OT- Jeff Otah over RB- Chris Johnson (5 pick's)

The one's in blue I am ok with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

LOL. Still not as bad imo as the Bears drafts, YAH! Lets trade Cutler for 5 1st rounders and get fuged for the next 15 years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a good thread, it's quite interesting and sad at the same time to see who your team passed over to draft someone else. I don't have to say much because it's a rarity Ozzie Newsome misses come Draft day but he certainly has his screw ups.

1997- Round 3 64: Jay Graham RB OVER CB Ronde Barber(Ronde was chosen 2 spots later)

2002- Round 2 52: Anthony Weaver DE OVER Antonio Bryant, Antwaan Randel El, Deion Branch

2005- Round 1 22: WR Mark Clayton OVER WR Roddy White

But the big one as everybody knows is giving up the possibility to draft Vince Wilfork by giving NE our 1st round pick in 2004 to select, Kyle fricken Boller!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2006- Round 2, Pick 58: CB- Richard Marshall over RB- Maurice Jones-Drew (2 pick's)

you wouldn't really need that because you have deangelo? and he was rnd 1 that year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2001 the eagles took freddie mitchell over chad johnson, reggie wayne, chris chambers and steve smith.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We could have had Steve Smith (NYG) instead of DJ.

In 2006 we could have had Marques Colston...rd.7 so take your pick on that one...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If only it was this simple! haha Certain guys just fit better in certain systems and that's often why they succeed some places and might not succeed others. This especially holds true with picks late into the draft.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i doubt freddie mitchell would fit in any team's scheme.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never regretted picking up Deshaun Foster or Biakabatuka. They were great guys with lots of talent but injuries stole their career. I wouldn't blame them for not panning out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never regretted picking up Deshaun Foster or Biakabatuka. They were great guys with lots of talent but injuries stole their career. I wouldn't blame them for not panning out.

Foster's failure was also in part to their trying to make him into a power back when he really wasn't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites