Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Matt Foley

Epicurus on God

58 posts in this topic

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?

Then he is not omnipotent.

Is he able, but not willing?

Then he is malevolent.

Is he both able, and willing?

Then whence cometh evil?

Is he neither able nor willing?

Then why call him God?

-- Epicurus

Discuss.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The canned answer of the faithful will boil down to free will.

No longer good enough for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Faith.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe is our Father, but He abandoned us, He's delinquent in child support, yet still demands we love and trust Him just because He is our dad.

Or as is actually the case, the kids still hold out hope he's not a total jerk and someday He is going to win the lottery and take care of us forever and love us again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can be a total jackass for a lifetime, have a deathbed change of heart (as long as it is "genuine" acceptance of JC) and still be saved.

Meanwhile, Ghandi burns.

Whatever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If people did the crap they do in his name....hell I would abondon people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?

Then he is not omnipotent.

Is he able, but not willing?

Then he is malevolent.

Is he both able, and willing?

Then whence cometh evil?

Is he neither able nor willing?

Then why call him God?

-- Epicurus

Discuss.

I went to church with my parents last Sunday, and the minister read a similar version of this and tried to address it. It basically boiled down to what Epi said earlier about free will. I wasn't very impressed by the response. Not convincing enough for me.

And I really just can't get over how this whole Eternal Salvation thing is almost entirely predicated on where you're born and what your parents believe.

That's the thing that makes me think it's all bullsh*t.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

^Indeed.

Which is the call for evangelism (in some religions, in others you don't have a chance no matter what you do), so all can hear the good news and be saved.

The problems arise when people say "no thanks".

At that point, you either get to burn in eternity for a seemingly inconsequential crime of questioning "authority", or need to be killed for your lack of acceptance if the group is radical.

Pass.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yup.

When all is said and done, it still all boils down to the fact that if you want to be religious, you must accept the idea that you are going to believe in something that has no rational foundation or tangibility. The idea of having "faith" to me is nothing more than believing in something that is completely subjective, arbitrary and impossible to prove.

That flies in the face of my desire to be a rational person.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well said.

I would only add that you also have to embrace the concept that other religions are completely "crazy", and laugh at the millions of followers of the other religions for being so "misguided".

Which is smart, since the propagation of the religious meme requires the in-group/out-group phenomenon in order to survive and really take off.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Calvin Pryor sucks he's getting cut at some point they just drafted two guys that can disguise their blitz looks as both Maye and Adams can do a lot of the same things. Jets safety's are going to be beastly, and it's not like their front is bad either with Richardson and Wilkerson but I don't even know who is playing QB for them
    • Some of you may remember that I'm a banjo player and studying classical guitar and music composition at East Carolina University. This was my senior year and for my senior composition recital I composed a 40 minute chamber opera. I heavily borrowed from traditional folk songs from The Anthology of American Folk Music (good composers borrow, great composers steal - Igor Stravinsky). The idea was original to be about a 20 minute telling of the story from The House Carpenter, but after researching the history of the ballad, I decided to do a telling of the Scottish Daemon Lover version of the story and mix elements of other ballads into the story. I used a lot of melodies from the ballads that I used, though a lot of times you'll have words from one ballad, mixed with the melody from another. It's a large thing so I'm giving a link to download it from dropbox. I hope some of you are interested enough to listen. If you're not, who can blame you, move along and enjoy your day. The Daemon Lover Below is a description of each scene. Act 1
      Scene 1
      The House Carpenter is building a cabin in the mountains win a demon comes to see him. He says he must give himself or one of his family as a sacrifice. The House Carpenter says to take his wife, because she has no ability to make money for their children. Scene 2
      Jane Reynolds is alone at him and tells the story of her long lost love, James Harris. The House Carpenter returns home and tells her that he has to go out of town on a business trip. Jane Reynolds tries to convince him to stay, but she is unsuccessful. Scene 3
      Jane Reynolds is alone at home when the demon comes to fetch her disguised as her lost love, James Harris. He convinces her to go away with him and leave her children with the House Carpenter. Act 2
      Scene 1
      Less than 2 weeks later the demon and Jane Reynolds are at sea. Jane Reynolds begins to have second thoughts about leaving her family for James Harris. The demon grows tired of this and reveals himself to her. Scene 2
      The House Carpenter is living with deep regret for what he’s done to Jane Reynolds. He reveals that she is a witch, and if he hangs himself the spell the demon has on her will be lifted. The House Carpenter hangs himself. Scene 3
      After the House Carpenter hangs himself, Jane Reynolds can feel her witchcraft return to her. She makes the demon a mortal man and punctures the boat. The boat sinks and Janes Reynolds and the demon drown at sea. Below are the program notes for the piece When I was fifteen my Grandfather pulled a banjo down from his attic and told me if I could learn to play it I could have it. A few years later I discovered The Anthology of American Folk Music edited by Harry Smith. The music contained on those six CDs opened my eyes to an “old, weird America” that I had no idea even existed. I learned how to play and sing every ballad on it, and it was these songs that gave me confidence to major in music. I’ve felt for the last couple years that the deeper I get into classical theory and technique, the further I’m getting away from these folk songs that have been so important to me. This chamber opera is my attempt to reconnect a little bit with some of these ballads. “The Daemon Lover” is a traditional Scottish ballad that is known as “The House Carpenter” in America. The story in this opera is basically that song, with a few story elements added that come from other folk songs. These songs include “The Old Lady and the Devil, Butcher’s Boy, The Cuckoo, Omie Wise, and The Drunkard’s Special. The melodies are also taken from folk songs, though often the words are taken from one folk song and sung with the melody of another one.