11 replies to this topic

[TheMaulClaw]

I know we invested heavily into the quarterback position this year. But I still think it would be amazing if we got Harbaugh and picked up Luck with the first pick and were able to keep the two together. Honestly I don't have much faith in Jimmy Clausen, but Luck is a specimen. What do you think?

Edited by TheMaulClaw, 14 October 2010 - 08:32 PM.

[Jackofalltrades]

I think this belongs in the draft thread.

I don't want Harbaugh either.

I don't want to throw the 2nd we spent on Jimmy away, nor has Clausen had time to see what he can do.

[Dpantherman]

Jimmy Clausen will be the QB next year. FO will be sure of it. so N-O

[TheMaulClaw]

Conventional wisdom would agree with you, that it would be unwise to throw a 2nd round pick away. But I think our situation is a bit different. Jimmy Clausen was drafted because he ran a similiar offensive system at Notre Dame, but when we hire a new coach all that sort of goes out the window. Not only that, we don't have a lot of money invested in Clausen. We have a chance to get a freak in Andrew Luck, if we have that opportunity I take it.

[mav1234]

If we get #1 pick and Luck is available and no defensive players have really separated themselves, we might draft him. If you have the #1, you can't always go with need if the top player is that much better.

I doubt we'll have the #1, though, and I doubt Luck will be up when we pick.

[Flying Lion]

The 49ers are taking both of them. Book it

[tarheelblue89]

If we get #1 pick and Luck is available and no defensive players have really separated themselves, we might draft him. If you have the #1, you can't always go with need if the top player is that much better.

I doubt we'll have the #1, though, and I doubt Luck will be up when we pick.

If we got the #1 pick, why wouldn't Luck be available?

[Delhommey]

First Mike Singletary and Ted Ginn, Jr. now this?!

The 49er's keep taking everything we want.

[Flying Lion]

First Mike Singletary and Ted Ginn, Jr. now this?!

The 49er's keep taking everything we want.

At least they aren't taking our refuse like the Bears.

What we need is some trades with the Jets. The last 2 times has wokred out pretty well for us.

[thunderraiden]

Jim Harbaurgh will be one of the best coaches ever, he is twice the coach of his brother in Baltimore... that words stated specifically from John Harbaurgh's mouth.

[2jakefansinva]

the huddle needs to create new forums like........

2011....

next year...

If we...

whatda think.....

How bout this......

If we have this pick and so and so is available.........

or maybe the powers that be can just create a "What If" thread and move post accordingly.

[Jhyler12]

Luck would be a bad choice...