Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Seltzer

Andrew Luck Run

7 posts in this topic

Watch his throwing highlights, then watch this video and tell me you don't want Andrew Luck with the #1 pick.

I don't normally get into future draft picks, but considering that he is 6'6", 240lbs, can throw the ball lights out and run like the wind with both speed and power. Plus, he went to Stanford so you know he has the ability to handle the mental part of the game.

If there is any consolation for this season, consider the opportunity to get a guy like Andrew Luck. We need a franchise QB to be competitive in the NFC South, and the Panthers have NEVER had an opportunity for a guy like this before...

I have heard the Andrew Luck talk all year, but now I have seen the evidence for myself and I am a believer. And I know I am not the first person to post this, but as someone that has attended every home game for the past 5 years, I need something like this to get through this season.

I hope Clausen shows promise over the next 6 weeks, but this franchise can not pass up an opportunity like this. Andrew Luck may be a once-in-a-lifetime type QB, and the Panthers should not pass this up even considering the other needs they have.

Does the possibility exist he may not be the best thing since sliced-bread? Of course, but every issue this team has will be made better with a franchise QB like this that can add 3-4 wins every season.

Look at our competition within the division. Every other team 2005 Saints, 2007 Falcons, 2008 Bucs were made better immediately when they drafted a franchise QB. Unfortanutely, I truly believe we will be on the outside looking in until we get a franchise QB. With a different coach/different offensive scheme we may have some success, but the only way to make the Panthers into a periennal contender is a franchise QB like Andrew Luck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I realize he won't run wild in the secondary at the NFL level, but having a big, talented passer who also poses a threat to run does not come along very offer.

Also the fact that he has an upper eschleon mental aptitude makes him someone to strongly consider. A lot of talented NFL scouts have him rated higher than Bradford or Ryan.

Obviously there are no guarantees he will translate his college success at the NFL level, but no one can dispute the impact a true franchise QB would have on this organization.

The Panthers have never had this in 16 years. Collins and Delhomme were close, but no there. The Falcons may just now have their first true franchise QB in 40 years. Same with the Saints and Brees. The book is still out on Freeman in Tampa.

But the truth is the Panthers need that type of QB to be competitive in our division for the long-haul, and Luck represents in my opinion the best chance to get there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When he faced a good team in oregon he didnt look so well. He was picked off and didnt place the ball all that well in the game. With that said he is still a top pick

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When he faced a good team in oregon he didnt look so well. He was picked off and didnt place the ball all that well in the game. With that said he is still a top pick

I wouldn't say he didn't look so well. He completed 29 passes for 341 yards and two TDs. Yes he also had two interceptions but if I remember right one of the picks was a tipped ball that bounced off the receivers hands.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wouldn't say he didn't look so well. He completed 29 passes for 341 yards and two TDs. Yes he also had two interceptions but if I remember right one of the picks was a tipped ball that bounced off the receivers hands.....
well...right at the end of the game it was thrown to the back of the endzone and had two defenders competing with the receiver for the jumpball and the duck came down with it. the first INT was just short of the receiver, but it was a pretty long ball that was thrown.

anyway...he did look pretty good that game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No way he does that to a DB in the NFL...but he most certainly put the hit stick on who ever that was from Cal lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Jesus. A 3-4 OLB at #8? Two major off-field character concerns in the 2nd round? Another slow WR in the 3rd? Never. Gonna. Happen. There's at least a decent chance that his top three picks won't even be on our draft board. Gettleman has said numerous times in the past that guys who aren't scheme fits for us aren't on our draft board. There goes McKinley. Given our past with guys like Carruth and Hardy, there's zero chance that Mixon is on our board. Given Robinson's off-field issues involving a stolen gun, I'd say there's a better than average chance that he's not on our board either. You'd be hard pressed to come up with a more unrealistic mock draft for the Panthers if you set out to try to do just that.
    • I can't say that any one of those guys ends up a Panther.  I think if Cam is there at 40 (which I doubt), then we would likely pull the trigger.
    • The need by some Americans here and across the country to demonize only select individuals for rioting (ahem, minorities) speaks directly to the fact that we've really made little actual progress since witnessing unrest in our streets dating back to the civil rights era. Ask yourself truthfully, what has really changed when the first thing some white people can think of even today in 2017 when they see a black person "rioting" is, "why are these black people so angry?"? But then white people rioting over a sporting event or a pumpkin festival is viewed as harmless tomfoolery.  If you as not only an American but also a basic human being fail to see the difference in the dynamic at play here as it pertains to the response to these instances, you are part of the problem whether you realize it or not.