Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Hammer

Jake----

112 posts in this topic

so who in that list do you not take over jake?

Romo (Locker Room Distraction

McNabb (Not very accurate)

Jason Campbell (SUCKS)

Shaun Hill (SUCKS)

Trent Edwards (SUCKS)

Matt Shaub (Only good because of receiver like Andre Johnson who is tall)

Tyler Thigpen (SUCKS)

Carson Palmer (SUCKS)

Brady Quinn (SUCKS)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like Jake. I agree with everyone that says who are you going to take if not him. Based upon whom is available or will be available. But according to that "wish list" I'd take quite a few of them over jake. But "it is what it is" as i've heard from time to time. Jake will have some compition this training camp. If they battle it out Jake will be forced to improve or it will be Moore or McCown. Who knows what any of our QB's will look like after our new QB coach gets to work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When Delhomme is gone I will just bitch about whomever his replacement is. He's average but good enough to win in most cases. Would it be nice to have a QB that was better than "good enough to win in most cases?" Yes. Is it possible to have one when you draft defense and focus on the running game? Not so much actually.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Romo (Locker Room Distraction

McNabb (Not very accurate)

Jason Campbell (SUCKS)

Shaun Hill (SUCKS)

Trent Edwards (SUCKS)

Matt Shaub (Only good because of receiver like Andre Johnson who is tall)

Tyler Thigpen (SUCKS)

Carson Palmer (SUCKS)

Brady Quinn (SUCKS)

romo plays with the biggest locker room distraction ever, and is liked by just about everyone (i don't like romo but i would still take him over jake)

mcnabb is a vet that led his team further than jake led his this year

campbell has gotten better each year he has been in the league

shaun hill- i agree with what you said

trent edwards played for the crappy bills and still put up numbers as good as jakes

matt schaub- your argument is terrible (if your defending jake you could say he is only good because of smitty)

tyler thigpen came in and started playing like a champ, his upside is huge compared to jake who is past his prime

carson palmer- are you serious? he is twice the qb jake is

brady quinn- young with a huge upside

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When Delhomme is gone I will just bitch about whomever his replacement is. He's average but good enough to win in most cases. Would it be nice to have a QB that was better than "good enough to win in most cases?" Yes. Is it possible to have one when you draft defense and focus on the running game? Not so much actually.

:iagree:

How many teams have Great QB's with a dominate run game?

How many teams have Great run game with Average QB? (I consider Jake an Average QB)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

--All of the following are QB's that are about the same skill-wise,

--All were good enough for ONE year-wonders, to get their teams to the Superbowl ONCE and then lost it

--None are great QB's or ever will be considered as such

Neil O'Donnell

Chris Chandler

Stan Humphries

Ken Anderson

Jake Delhomme

IMO, if we are to get back to the Superbowl, and win it next time, we need to dump the idea of the One-year wonder-boy QB and try to get a QB that can LEAD us there over and over

We need a Roethlisberger, Brady, Montana, Aikman, etc...

NO MORE POOR-BOY QB'S !!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

--All of the following are QB's that are about the same skill-wise,

--All were good enough for ONE year-wonders, to get their teams to the Superbowl ONCE and then lost it

--None are great QB's or ever will be considered as such

Neil O'Donnell

Chris Chandler

Stan Humphries

Ken Anderson

Jake Delhomme

IMO, if we are to get back to the Superbowl, and win it next time, we need to dump the idea of the One-year wonder-boy QB and try to get a QB that can LEAD us there over and over

We need a Roethlisberger, Brady, Montana, Aikman, etc...

NO MORE POOR-BOY QB'S !!!!!

Carolina has always been a smashmouth football team that loves to run the ball. I highly doubt we are going to see a Tom Brady like QB on our team for a long long time if ever.

And I think calling Delhomme a "Poor-Boy QB" or one year wonder is pretty damn arrogant. If you think you can do better, go try out for QB.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

--All of the following are QB's that are about the same skill-wise,

--All were good enough for ONE year-wonders, to get their teams to the Superbowl ONCE and then lost it

--None are great QB's or ever will be considered as such

Neil O'Donnell

Chris Chandler

Stan Humphries

Ken Anderson

Jake Delhomme

IMO, if we are to get back to the Superbowl, and win it next time, we need to dump the idea of the One-year wonder-boy QB and try to get a QB that can LEAD us there over and over

We need a Roethlisberger, Brady, Montana, Aikman, etc...

NO MORE POOR-BOY QB'S !!!!!

This poor boy QB has led us to the playoffs in THREE of his 4 four full seasons. Dumbest nonsense I've seen in a while

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The fact it, Jake is a aging, sub-par Quarterback coming off Tommy John surgery who has pretty bad mechanics and makes some pretty awful mistakes. But people forget all about that because he has a 5-3 record in the playoffs. Which, if I might add, we have gotten less and less far in the playoffs each time he has taken us. I am grateful for where Jake has taken us the last 5 years, but after this season, I don't see him with the team anymore. With the running game that Carolina has, we just need a quarterback who minimizes mistakes. We need a QB who understands the game a bit more than Jake does. Sometimes it is OK to punt the ball, and Jake doesn't seem to understand that. Maybe our new QB's coach will help? Who knows.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts