72 replies to this topic

[thecarolinaswagger]

who gives a crap,we didnt win anything with him.yes he was and is still a good receiver,but he has attitude problems and to move forward in this organization you can't have veteran players acting like assholes every time a rookie makes a mistake. trust me you have all seen it, he has made is share of mistakes over the years too. throw in a whole new coaching staff next season with probably another rookie qb, new plays and terminology and basically steve smith will be just like a 35 year old rookie.if he wants to leave then leave. all i know is at the end of the day players come and go. somebody wore #89 before steve smith (rae carruth) and somebody will wear #89 after him. the logo will always remain,real fans will always remain.

[Humble Dew]

yeah, and he shouldn't fly either!

[rayzor]

[grateflday]

:willy_nilly: goodness. He is playing like an a**hole?? I am not sure what games you are watching but Smith still seams to be playing is heart out, I still see him blocking on run and pass plays not thrown his way, and he has pretty much kept his mouth shut despite the fact this team has had ZERO QB play and a horrible offense for almost two season's now. In addition this whole "he wants to leave" is still pure speculation.

[Baschski]

Despite the fact that everyone wants to talk about Smith's "attitude problems," he's done a pretty damn good job of containing himself given the circumstances.

[Happy Panther]

In addition this whole "he wants to leave" is still pure speculation.

But he put his house up for sale and had a CLOSED DOOR meeting with JR!!

CLOSED DOOR DAMNIT!

[Stroupe-a-loop]

But he put his house up for sale and had a CLOSED DOOR meeting with JR!!

CLOSED DOOR DAMNIT!

Does anybody have open door meetings anymore? Where is the trust? I blame Michael Corleone and Kay Adams for all of this.

[Pimpdaddy]

If he leaves he is abandoning the fans and team that made him what he is, an awesome ballplayer. We stood by and supported him during his shortcomings, retire a Panther Smity.

[Happy Panther]

If he leaves he is abandoning the fans and team that made him what he is, an awesome ballplayer. We stood by and supported him during his shortcomings, retire a Panther Smity.

[KSpan]

If he leaves he is abandoning the fans and team that made him what he is, an awesome ballplayer. We stood by and supported him during his shortcomings, retire a Panther Smity.

I don't really disagree, but I can't fault the guy for wanting to win now - his window is closing. It's fairly clear that Carolina is at least year or two away from being back to truly competitive (although I do believe there is a LOT of talent on this team) and I'm sure that Steve wants a ring. I would miss seeing him in a Panthers uni, but it's not like he'd be LeBron-ing the Panthers.

[Snake]

I mean really I cant blame the guy. We are having a bad year. I mean every other team in the league never has a bad year so Yea he should want to be traded. We are going to suck forever now so whats the use of having Smith. Dear GOd whY Do wE SuK sooo MuCh........

[Proudiddy]

*yawn* nice attention ***** post. He's a player on our team, not your ex-girlfriend.

[ThatGuy]

Yeah lets just get rid of anybody who shows any emotion or acts like they give a damn that they are losing. Everybody on that team is an adult and they need to take responsibility for what they are doing. Jimmy is sucking and needs to know it. Dont baby an adult. If he needs a bottle on the field then hes the one that should go. Sure smith has done some stupid things but not nearly as bad as Vick and theres lots of retards on here that want him here. He tortured dogs and drowned them and all that other crap. cmon now dude. so smitty punched somebody. big deal. its a physical emotional game. We need more people like him. Not just a bunch of robots who go through the motions.

[Pimpdaddy]

I don't really disagree, but I can't fault the guy for wanting to win now - his window is closing. It's fairly clear that Carolina is at least year or two away from being back to truly competitive (although I do believe there is a LOT of talent on this team) and I'm sure that Steve wants a ring. I would miss seeing him in a Panthers uni, but it's not like he'd be LeBron-ing the Panthers.

Yea New England gets rid of guys with this talent every season, I mean its not like anybody is going to know who he was in 15-20 years... The honorable thing to do is retire a Panther but go for it Smitty, whatever.

[Third Degree]

How has he acted with class this year considering what he's said? Are we going by his standards? It still isn't good.

How often do you hear Beason bitching about Godfrey?