Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Mr. Scot

Prayer question for the non-religious

40 posts in this topic

How bout if I respond this way...

Do you honestly believe Zod was "just asking an honest question" when he threw out his "should he have prayed" thread?

You'd have to ask Zod what his motivation is/was for the thread

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How bout if I respond this way...

Do you honestly believe Zod was "just asking an honest question" when he threw out his "should he have prayed" thread?

Didn't Zod explain himself anyway?

Um, I believe I started the thread with legitimate questions that can have multiple points of view , and never labeled any of them as stupid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So, for some, let's say your child is on the verge of passing, there's not a thing anyone can do for them, no hope of any sort, you still wouldn't take a chance on praying?

Nope.

Now, another question might be.....would the faithful be a bit tempted to curse his god for either

a) causing the affliction ?

B) not making it go away ?

Since clearly it would be within His almighty power to do just that?

As the father of 2 healthy children, the very thought of this scenario is difficult.

But something as awful as sick/dying children does not bring on thoughts of a hereafter or a deity, but rather the obvious lack of one.

To me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's say you're in an absolutely desperate situation, in fear of your life or perhaps the life (or lives) of someone you love. Taking stock of the situation, you realize for certain there's absolutely nothing you can do to save yourself or your loved ones.

Do you offer up a prayer in the hope that maybe God will be there and grant you a miracle, or do you stick to your guns that there is no God or that prayer is futile and not bother?

No. Why, out of the billions of people am I somehow special? Am I the only one in an unfortunate situation? Life is unforgiving, and when something like that happens, you have to accept it. Look at all the people dieing in third world countries of starvation, or even over in Israel because of religion, those people didn't deserve to die, but they unfortunately did. It's not like some god came down from the heavens and saved them all, nothing happened. What explanation do religious people have to say about that? What about all the good, innocent people that die every day? And why is god going to save you for some reason above all people?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You'd have to ask Zod what his motivation is/was for the thread

I'm amused that you've known Zod for a while, you don't really know me at all, but you think you can read my purpose for this thread while you have to "not speculate" or look for a quote to get his :rolleyes:

Now, another question might be.....would the faithful be a bit tempted to curse his god for either

a) causing the affliction ?

B) not making it go away ?

Since clearly it would be within His almighty power to do just that?

As the father of 2 healthy children, the very thought of this scenario is difficult.

But something as awful as sick/dying children does not bring on thoughts of a hereafter or a deity, but rather the obvious lack of one.

To me.

That's the flipside of it, and not only do I recognize it as a possibility. I've descended into that very thing myself in the past. And I'm not alone in that regard.

I came out of it over time, but it does indeed happen. Some don't recover their faith. I did.

Without going into too much theology, the suffering of the cross is the traditional Christian answer. Point being that God may not have removed our suffering, but he has subjected himself to it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your purpose for this thread is obvious amd transparent, Mr Scot. Don't feign amusement to deflect the fact that I nailed you on your ulterior motive for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your purpose for this thread is obvious amd transparent, Mr Scot. Don't feign amusement to deflect the fact that I nailed you on your ulterior motive for it.

Yep. Nailed me. I am ashamed but amazed by your insight :lol::rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am a non believer who has been in some scary situations. For example a car accident, where I was hit by a speeding drunk driver and one where I was on an airplane and we were told our landing gear wouldn't go down and we could see them on the runway below preparing for an emergency landing and neither of those times did I pray to anyone even in my mind. In fact, I joked at the time with my ex who was flying with me that the situation likely made a convert out of some people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm amused that Mr Scot thinks he knows me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I have a weird suspicion we're really interested in Ross to many's dismay.  Last year proved in too many wats how much we need a playmaker and in a major way.  Looking just at in-game skills, Ross is the best playmaker in the draft.  I feel better about him than the board did about Brandin Cooks in his draft.  We need to draft someone clearly ahead of Shepard/Johnson and to be our third in volume receiving option behind Olsen and KB.   I can also see that causing a stir here so it'd be an entertaining summer for inline fandom.    
    •   Allen is an intriguing prospect. I just wish I had more faith in his versatility. IMO, we need DE more than another DT. Even if that DT is pretty dang good.   Ross? Really? I love everything about him. Except...those knees, and that shoulder. Small guys with injury problems in college? Not high on my list. But hey, that's just me. We can still get a talented kid who doesn't have injury concerns. Just not at 8.   Now a CB? That tickles my fancy. As much as I would love a Hog Mollie at DE. A top flight CB does not repulse me. But...to me, CB is like WR. We should still be able to get a talented kid, even in the 2nd.   Man. I don't know. Part of me wants that Hog Mollie DE. Part of me wants a kid that can scare a Defense. I just am of the mind that we need Offense more so than Defense. But, Fournette is the only Offensive player worthy of that 8 slot. Wishy washy is my name.   Other than that. Thanks for playing.