Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Panthers_Lover

Where's the Joe the Plumber-type vetting?

120 posts in this topic

this really isn't anything like JTP at all

Explain why it isn't ....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

when does her country album come out?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why is it reaching? She asked the president a question, told her story, just as Joe did. Why are we taking her at face value? Why is the media not asking simple questions, at least, about her and her adult son and their circumstances? Was their house in foreclosure? Why didn't they apply for public housing a year ago -- I know there's a 2-year waiting period, they said, but they'd be another year closer (maybe they did, but the implication is that they didn't)? What has the son done to try to find a job? Why is the media taking everything she/they said as gospel? I'm simply asking why the media (and you, apparently) is taking a different view of her than they did of Joe? It is, in fact, a double standard. You admitted it, but it's ok with you why?

No, I think it's different due to motivation. Joe the liar, I mean Plumber was doing his song and dance as a politically-motivated piece of propaganda.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Explain why it isn't ....

well, this woman hasn't become a major talking point, hasn't whored herself out to the media, hasn't come out with a book or country album, hasn't allowed herself to be ridiculously exploited, hasn't pretended she's a barometer for what a segment of society is thinking, hasn't taken a job as a war correspondent she wasn't qualified to have, and isn't working for a major news network now as a consultant.

i guess when she does all of those things she could be vetted to make sure she wasn't lying about half the things she said.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well, this woman hasn't become a major talking point, hasn't whored herself out to the media, hasn't come out with a book or country album, hasn't allowed herself to be ridiculously exploited, hasn't pretended she's a barometer for what a segment of society is thinking, hasn't taken a job as a war correspondent she wasn't qualified to have, and isn't working for a major news network now as a consultant.

i guess when she does all of those things she could be vetted to make sure she wasn't lying about half the things she said.

Ahem...he was vetted before he did any of those things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ahem...he was vetted before he did any of those things.

clearly, which is why they didn't know he wasn't a registered plumber or couldn't legally join a union in ohio.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, I think it's different due to motivation. Joe the liar, I mean Plumber was doing his song and dance as a politically-motivated piece of propaganda.

1) Even if that's true about Joe, how would the media have known that without asking more questions than just simply taking his word?

2) How would the media (or you) know anything about her motivation at all, without asking more questions?

You and the media have made huge assumptions and have taken her at face value when they didn't Joe. Why is it different?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

clearly, which is why they didn't know he wasn't a registered plumber or couldn't legally join a union in ohio.

And this woman lives in a car with her son. Do you suppose maybe, just maybe, there are some things in her past that aren't on the up and up?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well, this woman hasn't become a major talking point, hasn't whored herself out to the media, hasn't come out with a book or country album, hasn't allowed herself to be ridiculously exploited, hasn't pretended she's a barometer for what a segment of society is thinking, hasn't taken a job as a war correspondent she wasn't qualified to have, and isn't working for a major news network now as a consultant.

i guess when she does all of those things she could be vetted to make sure she wasn't lying about half the things she said.

Do you really not understand how ridiculous all that sounds?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites