Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Mr. Scot

Yasinskas Speculation: "Real Chance" Smith is Traded

197 posts in this topic

Financially, the Panthers will be so incredibly below any reasonably likely future salary cap that we'd have no need to part ways with Steve Smith or any other desirable player for that matter.

Assuming a CBA does not get done before draft day (seems a safe bet), then we won't see Smith leave unless he is demanding to leave. If he does leave, we will require immediate compensation with players in positions of need, and specifically not picks for future drafts.

The misleading and uniformly negative public relations press against Richardson and the Panthers franchise practically demands that when the new CBA returns, we will be spending that margin under cap on roster additions. Although it is entirely possible, it is hard to illustrate any reasonably likely scenario where we lose Smith and upgrade on offense at the same time. Proven WRs are hard to come by.

FA Offensive linemen that could be in the mix:

We could use Ryan Harris from Denver, and they need a receiver.

Atlanta (who needs another receiver) has several offensive linemen available, and honestly I think our DBs know how to beat Steve Smith. Risky, but a possibility.

Lyle Sendlein from Arizona, and they could use another WR.

There'd be more to it than that of course.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have thought for a while that he would be gone, and not necessarily just because he wanted out. Rivera has talked about seeing how SS fits and what is best for the organization. Other people around the team have hinted that Steve was a problem last year with Clausen and before that with other young receivers.

It is very possible that Rivera just wants him gone. You can't develop a young team if one of your high profile vets is stunting that development. If that's the case he has to go.

I love Steve for what he has done for the organization and the joy he has brought to us as fans, but it is probably best for both parties to go their separate ways.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Financially, the Panthers will be so incredibly below any reasonably likely future salary cap that we'd have no need to part ways with Steve Smith or any other desirable player for that matter.

Assuming a CBA does not get done before draft day (seems a safe bet), then we won't see Smith leave unless he is demanding to leave. If he does leave, we will require immediate compensation with players in positions of need, and specifically not picks for future drafts.

The misleading and uniformly negative public relations press against Richardson and the Panthers franchise practically demands that when the new CBA returns, we will be spending that margin under cap on roster additions. Although it is entirely possible, it is hard to illustrate any reasonably likely scenario where we lose Smith and upgrade on offense at the same time. Proven WRs are hard to come by.

FA Offensive linemen that could be in the mix:

We could use Ryan Harris from Denver, and they need a receiver.

Atlanta (who needs another receiver) has several offensive linemen available, and honestly I think our DBs know how to beat Steve Smith. Risky, but a possibility.

Lyle Sendlein from Arizona, and they could use another WR.

There'd be more to it than that of course.

Extensions to Beason, Kalil and Johnson will whack a huge amount on our cap, considering all were still on their rookie deals.

Any attempt to bring back Anderson, or TD will also come with a few $$$ attached. Whilst we may well be below the cap now, we won't be almost certainly once the dust settles on new contracts. Add in a #1 overall draft pick, the rest of the draft class and presumably a few free agents (not nec high priced...) and you quickly see that you are wildly off base.

The vibes being given off are nothing to do with finances, so I think you have missed the point here. What is being suggested is that Smith might well want to move on, or at least expect too much too soon from this team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chargers or Ravens

Ravens are AFC, could probably use him. Only the geography makes me wonder there.

The Bengals could conceivably use him, but I think he'd nix that and retire.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we do trade Smitty, we better damn well sign a good FA WR. Green is no Smith (yet), and we don't even know we'd draft him. Sorry, but Clausen/Moore to LaFell/Gettis/Green/Edwards is ugly.

IBbutwehavetehShockey!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Extensions to Beason, Kalil and Johnson will whack a huge amount on our cap, considering all were still on their rookie deals.

Any attempt to bring back Anderson, or TD will also come with a few $$$ attached. Whilst we may well be below the cap now, we won't be almost certainly once the dust settles on new contracts. Add in a #1 overall draft pick, the rest of the draft class and presumably a few free agents (not nec high priced...) and you quickly see that you are wildly off base.

The vibes being given off are nothing to do with finances, so I think you have missed the point here. What is being suggested is that Smith might well want to move on, or at least expect too much too soon from this team.

I am not going to disagree with you, but will ask you to PUT UP OR SHUT UP. Let's see your numbers, and be specific. I've been using the USAToday salary information, and a few other more dubious sources as well where the figures only seemed correct to me. But this has been a matter of interest of mine for a long time, so I do care enough to correct any misperceptions I may have.

While I know there is a margin of error for each player's salary that I think I know, and another margin of error regarding what the cap will be when it returns, I've arrived at ballpark figures that I think are heavily stacked in favor of us making roster additions.

So let's hear it. Put up some numbers that total up the way you;ve illustrated (that the Panthers won't have much money under the 2011 cap to spend on new talent other than picks) , and if I disagree then you'll hear it soon enough.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not going to disagree with you, but will ask you to PUT UP OR SHUT UP. Let's see your numbers, and be specific. I've been using the USAToday salary information, and a few other more dubious sources as well where the figures only seemed correct to me. But this has been a matter of interest of mine for a long time, so I do care enough to correct any misperceptions I may have.

While I know there is a margin of error for each player's salary that I think I know, and another margin of error regarding what the cap will be when it returns, I've arrived at ballpark figures that I think are heavily stacked in favor of us making roster additions.

So let's hear it. Put up some numbers that total up the way you;ve illustrated (that the Panthers won't have much money under the 2011 cap to spend on new talent other than picks) , and if I disagree then you'll hear it soon enough.

New to message boards? Talk about an over reaction to someone quoting you :rolleyes:

First of all I never said we wouldn't have much cap room left, I said we would be over the cap floor.

Second of all it's impossible for me to tell you what contract extensions our players are going to receive. That said look at the top 10 MLBs, the top 5 Cs and somewhere around the top 25 DEs for a rough estimate on those three alone.

Third, our #1 pick is likely going to be not as expensive as Bradford, but not as cheap as the rookie scaling.

We will not be under the cap floor, so Smith being traded will be a completely non-financial move.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:icon_bs:Yeah, that's pretty much the kind of response I thought you'd make.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After a few wins he might change his mind. Smith just wants to win and no one on the coaching staff really did last year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.