Limbaugh said he felt that McNabb was overrated even when the team was winning. I'm sorry, but I agree. And if McNabb comes out and wins a Super Bowl, THEN I'll change my mind about him. Just like I did with Elway and Manning. And yes, I held the "no Super Bowl win" thing against Marino and still do, quite frankly.
So Marino wasnt an elite QB because he never won a Super Bowl? Are Trent Dilfer, Brad Johnson, Doug Williams, and Mark Rypien elite HOFers because they did? Super Bowl wins are a TEAM accomplishment. If McNabb did win a Super Bowl I doubt you'd change your mind, you would just as easily credit the defense for the win. Obama won the Presidency and the trust of the American people, has that stopped you from disliking him? LOL.