163 replies to this topic

[Happy Panther]

[B]Steve Smith			      Jerry Rice[/B]	
	Game	Aggregate		Game	Aggregate
1	178	178		             87   87
2	156	334		            167	  254
3				             87	  341
4				            181	  522
5				             71	  593
6				             43	  636
7				             21	  657
8				            108	  765
9				            111	  876
10				            161	  1037
11				            149	  1186
12				             67	  1253
13				             32	  1285
14				            121	  1406
15				            289	  1695
16				            153	  1848

Needs to average: 108 yards per game to surpass the single season record

[csx]

Needs to hold on to the ball.

[weymouthst]

Possible? Yes.

Plausible? weeeeeell..

[Happy Panther]

Rice finished strong too

[CarolinaNCSU]

No chance IMO. Cam won't continue to throw for 400 yards a week, and I'm hoping a running game shows up starting next week.

[Woodcookedbbq]

If Smith ever gets a ring, he'll be a HOFer for sure.

[Varking]

If Smith ever gets a ring, he'll be a HOFer for sure.

False. He needs to put up monster numbers and still get a ring.

[Happy Panther]

If Smith ever gets a ring, he'll be a HOFer for sure.

I would say he needs 3 or 4 more very good years as well.

[blackcatgrowl]

Needs to hold on to the ball.

:iagree:

I have to wonder what was going through his head to extend out the football... not forward... but to the side/slightly behind him.

[Happy Panther]

:iagree:

I have to wonder what was going through his head to extend out the football... not forward... but to the side/slightly behind him.

It cost us the game too.

[KSpan]

It cost us the game too.

Accidentally pied you there... While it was certainly damaging, no one play costs a game. Stalling out in the red zone, turnovers overall, giving up homerun TDs, not converting 4th down - all a part of the equation.

[Dpantherman]

It cost us the game too.

You should make a thread about it.

[Happy Panther]

You should make a thread about it.

I'm actually going to make a 2nd thread and watch everybody get really angry.

[Varking]

Steve Smith has 634 catches for 9218 yards, and 54 TDs.
Cris Carter has 1101 catches for 13899 yards and 130 tds.

I will give you another example of a good player who won't get into the Hall but is/was better than Steve Smith... Jimmy Smith.

From 96-05 when he retired, only Marvin Harrison had more catches or yards than him. When he retired he had more catches than any wr in the hall.

862 catches, 12287 yards, 67 tds. Only fumbled 12 times, losing 4 in his career. Steve is sitting at 29 fumbles losing 11. Neither guy will be enshrined.

Keenan McCardell has similar numbers, along with many other players. You have to do more as a WR in the NFL to get in. It is unfortunate, but it is true. And Jimmy Smith has a ring as a Cowboy.

[Happy Panther]

You are not taking into account that Smith will break the all time single season receiving record this year