Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Carolina Fan

Armanti Edwards

106 posts in this topic

Kick return blocking and punt return blocking isn't remotely the same thing.

For one thing you can't try to block a kickoff, it seems like our punt return team try to block the kick every time, never even get close, and leave Edwards with 5 guys unblocked coming right at him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Armanti WILL be on the team next year, doesnt matter what his play this year was like. His first year was basically a red shirt year. If he doesnt improve in 2012 it will be his last. No way they give up on him after 2 seasons. Not Hurneys MO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can blame him for not showing enough to get on the field yet as a WR, or make his own path as a returner as the better returners do. How much more time will you give the kid before you finally see he doesn't have "it". Will yo give him all of next year too?

are you really surprised that a 4 year college quarterback is not a starting caliber WR on a TE reliant team? Hell why isn't Jimmy starting WR either? Armanti has been put in a crappy situation (that said, its probably the only situation possible that would give him even a chance to stick in the league). But theres nothing to blame HIM for. Except for being an undersized QB tryna make it in the league. Its not like he doesnt work his ass off

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:lol: What a cop out response.

Pilares has had just two decent returns this year, btw, in a completely different element d our special teams.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Perhaps, but then again Steve Smith is probably still the best PR on the team, but he hasn't done it in years.

Starters are almost never return specialists.

No perhaps, the numbers done lie. Also there is a deference in starting your Pro bowl WR at PR and starting your #2/nickle CB at PR.

Also the question has to be asked, What else can AE do? We already know Capt. can play at CB but AE is yet to even get a snap at WR from two head coaches. That says something right there.

I guess next year will be his break out season though just like Jarrett broke out last year...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just don't understand why the Armanti homers think that any criticism of AE or the pick comes from some hatred for App State. I don't care if Ahmadinejad is our punt returner...all I care is how he PERFORMS. AE might be a great guy, and he was great for App... but so far, the proof is in the pudding. He is not an NFL caliber player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No perhaps, the numbers done lie. Also there is a deference in starting your Pro bowl WR at PR and starting your #2/nickle CB at PR.

Also the question has to be asked, What else can AE do? We already know Capt. can play at CB but AE is yet to even get a snap at WR from two head coaches. That says something right there.

It sure does, god knows Capt had to beat out all kinds of talented corners to start for our team. Poor Armanti can't beat our any of our scrub WR's, he must suck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If only our defense could force the opponent to punt more often, then Armanti would have been given more opportunities.

DERP

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kick return blocking and punt return blocking isn't remotely the same thing.

For one thing you can't try to block a kickoff, it seems like our punt return team try to block the kick every time, never even get close, and leave Edwards with 5 guys unblocked coming right at him.

Pilares has shown that either we do have ST guys that can do as they are asked, or he makes his own holes. I know PR blocking is different, but it's the same guys out there working. It's been how long since we had a KR TD? That may scream we have inept ST coaching, but at the same time makes Armanti come off poorly now that Pilares has had two solid returns in two weeks. You must also ask yourself if the guy that was blocked in the back would've affected Armanti's return making this thread pointless.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok then. Bump this when he puts up good stats as a WR. And if we ever get "good blocking" (Pilares likes our blocking, btw), bump this when he gets multiple nice returns. I'll eat crow.

That won't happen though. So stick to your project excuse, coach excuse, and poor blocking excuse.

Of course pilares will say he likes our blocking, he's not gonna call out or Special Teams.. Just sayin'

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites