Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Black

David Aldridge: Gerald Wallce is the next to go

52 posts in this topic

I can understand why the Bobcats stoop pat at 5 and 13 (when they needed bodies) because there was no evidence that Paul was going to be as good as he has been...I think DW, RF and CP were all rated close with CP and DW considered marginally better.

I actually agree with you. At the time we needed a pg and a big man. May was always healthy in college and looked like he could do pretty good in the NBA. You never know in the NBA if guys are gonna pan out so there is no point on bitching about past picks. I never really felt Raymond would be very good in the NBA but i guess he was the best option at the point for us. Dont remember all the point guards in that draft but at 5 i think he was the best.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im not sure where you are going with any of this. Honestly maybe i missed something. Okafor trade? We drafted him. Weren't we in our first year when we drafted Oak? So how would we have thrown stuff at the magic for Howard. Anyway i dont mind Brown clearing house with the way things have been going but he better not bail out on us. If he sticks around he can make this team special if not we have just been set back a few more years.

The Bobcats traded the 4th pick for the 2nd pick in that draft, which ended up being Okafor. So, yeah the Bobcats traded up for Okafor. The Magic were flip flopping between taking Oak or Howard so the Cats could have traded the 2nd pick with some players or picks for that #1 pick.

I dont mind the Cats clearing house either but it'd be nice for them to have an exiting player in return. It pisses me off that the Bobcats have wiffed on so many players. My fantasy bobcats would be, and yes, I know if we got anyone of these guys we wouldnt be in position to draft the "guy" the next draft but for fun the lineup could have been:

Dwight Howard

--signed PF--

Crash

Roy

CP3

That lineup would seel alot of tickets and win alot of games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually agree with you. At the time we needed a pg and a big man. May was always healthy in college and looked like he could do pretty good in the NBA. You never know in the NBA if guys are gonna pan out so there is no point on bitching about past picks. I never really felt Raymond would be very good in the NBA but i guess he was the best option at the point for us. Dont remember all the point guards in that draft but at 5 i think he was the best.

May wasnt healthy at all in college. He had knee and weight problems the first 2 years at Carolina. He lost some weight and got in shape, thanks to Roy Williams, which allowed him to have a very good championship year. May has a ton of skills but zero work ethic and that should have been a huge red flag. Think Derrick Coleman light.

Felton was ranked as the 3rd PG prospect in that draft on everyones board. There was debate between Paul and Williams on which would be the best PG, but Felton was always ranked behind those 2 guys.

I agree that Felton had to be the pick at 5 being the chips fell like they did. I. howerver, thought he would be a better pro than he has turned out to be. I always knew Williams and Paul would be better than Felton but not by this much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bobcats traded the 4th pick for the 2nd pick in that draft, which ended up being Okafor. So, yeah the Bobcats traded up for Okafor. The Magic were flip flopping between taking Oak or Howard so the Cats could have traded the 2nd pick with some players or picks for that #1 pick.

I dont mind the Cats clearing house either but it'd be nice for them to have an exiting player in return. It pisses me off that the Bobcats have wiffed on so many players. My fantasy bobcats would be, and yes, I know if we got anyone of these guys we wouldnt be in position to draft the "guy" the next draft but for fun the lineup could have been:

Dwight Howard

--signed PF--

Crash

Roy

CP3

That lineup would seel alot of tickets and win alot of games.

Ahh ok. I wasn't talking poo i honestly couldn't remember. I thought we had the 2nd pick guess i forgot we traded up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im not sure where you are going with any of this. Honestly maybe i missed something. Okafor trade? We drafted him. Weren't we in our first year when we drafted Oak? So how would we have thrown stuff at the magic for Howard. Anyway i dont mind Brown clearing house with the way things have been going but he better not bail out on us. If he sticks around he can make this team special if not we have just been set back a few more years.

I think he's referring to the fact that we traded up to the #2 spot to draft Okafor. We traded the clips the #4 and #33 picks who ended up being Shaun Livingston and Lionel Chalmers (who??) for Okafor. Even though I don't love Okafor, it ended up being a pretty good trade.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought Brown said we have too many outside shooter who can't play D. Trading Wallace after trading J-rich is a mistake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bobcats traded the 4th pick for the 2nd pick in that draft, which ended up being Okafor. So, yeah the Bobcats traded up for Okafor. The Magic were flip flopping between taking Oak or Howard so the Cats could have traded the 2nd pick with some players or picks for that #1 pick.

I dont mind the Cats clearing house either but it'd be nice for them to have an exiting player in return. It pisses me off that the Bobcats have wiffed on so many players. My fantasy bobcats would be, and yes, I know if we got anyone of these guys we wouldnt be in position to draft the "guy" the next draft but for fun the lineup could have been:

Dwight Howard

--signed PF--

Crash

Roy

CP3

That lineup would seel alot of tickets and win alot of games.

The thing about the Okafor-Howard deal was that nobody knew quite how good Howard was going to be. After all, he was yet another 18 year old with no college experience being drafted first overall. In fact, most analysts and fans alike thought we got a steal with Okafor at #2 since he was a star in college and was a proven winner. I agree with your sentiments about the other picks though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing about the Okafor-Howard deal was that nobody knew quite how good Howard was going to be. After all, he was yet another 18 year old with no college experience being drafted first overall. In fact, most analysts and fans alike thought we got a steal with Okafor at #2 since he was a star in college and was a proven winner. I agree with your sentiments about the other picks though.

True. There was alot of debate between Okafor and Howard and which would be the better pro. Most agreed that Okafor was at his ceiling and would be a 13/10 guy in the NBA. He also was known to have back problems. Dwight was very skinny, athletic, and really didnt have anything but a limited inside game but he had a higher ceiling than Okafor. I dont think anyone thought he would be able to put on as much muscle as the Man Child has. The writing, for me, was on the wall when Okafor turned down a one-on-one workout against Howard, at Howards suggestion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh, and the argument that Paul wasn't rated as better than Felton prior to the draft is and that they were so close is only valid through baby blue tinted glasses. The reason they didn't make the trade is that they were more interested in selling some extra tickets by picking the two UNC guys. Same reason that Morrison was selected.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bobcats traded the 4th pick for the 2nd pick in that draft, which ended up being Okafor. So, yeah the Bobcats traded up for Okafor. The Magic were flip flopping between taking Oak or Howard so the Cats could have traded the 2nd pick with some players or picks for that #1 pick.

I dont mind the Cats clearing house either but it'd be nice for them to have an exiting player in return. It pisses me off that the Bobcats have wiffed on so many players. My fantasy bobcats would be, and yes, I know if we got anyone of these guys we wouldnt be in position to draft the "guy" the next draft but for fun the lineup could have been:

Dwight Howard

--signed PF--

Crash

Roy

CP3

That lineup would seel alot of tickets and win alot of games.

That's not as unrealistic as it might seem on the surface. Howard and EO50 had similar rookie seasons, so if we had taken Howard instead (like you, I think we might have been able to put together an offer Orlando would have accepted), we likely would have still ended up with a very similar draft pick. So, most likely, we would have been in a position to make the proposed trade from Atlanta, and picked CP3. And in Howard's 2nd year, he still wasn't the dominant player you see today, and CP3 was going through his growing pains, and really wasn't much better than what we had...which would have been magnified with our coaching. So, again, it is reasonable to believe that we would have been in a similar position to take Roy instead of Ammo.

The thing is that if we had played our cards right, we could be an elite team right now (of course that's easy to say with 20/20 hindsight). It wasn't until Howard's 3rd season and CP3's 2nd that each exploded into the stars they are. And by that time, we would have already picked up Roy. So while we would have had to have been smart and savvy (neither of which describe Bickerstaff as a GM), it is very conceivable that our lineup could look like your fantasy lineup.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites