Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

ClarkCam

Wide Receiver

70 posts in this topic

Naanee was garbage,no doubt but,for some reason,Rivera liked him. Whenever Lafell was in he produced solid numbers and gained valuable experience. Saw no reason what so ever to question Lafell's hands. Edwards,at the right price and mind-set, would give us the receiving corps needed for a legit play-off run. Draft exclusively defense,which kept us from getting there last season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

from 08-2010 Edwards has like a 14% drop rate, I think we ranked in the low 40's, should have clarified my point a little more...

Lafell had a bad 2010 drop rate around 11% and this past year under 6%, so I would say he has improved on his second year, and Edwards has had 14% between 08-10, he didn't really play in 2011....

You know what Smiths was? 17% percent. Doesn't mean he's a bad wide out...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You know what Smiths was? 17% percent. Doesn't mean he's a bad wide out...

Yeah I agree, but I just think bringing in vets will limit the progression of our young talent when it comes to the WR position, especially when we have some many holes on DEF, the GM has to use the remaining money wisely, IMO and bringing in a VET WR, I feel goes against that philosophy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I agree, but I just think bringing in vets will limit the progression of our young talent when it comes to the WR position, especially when we have some many holes on DEF, the GM has to use the remaining money wisely, IMO and bringing in a VET WR, I feel goes against that philosophy.

I can get a handle on your view on this subject and agree to an extent. It still wouldn't hurt taking a look at Edwards, especially if he comes for cheap. He's honestly the only wide out I'd want to consider in the FA market right now, just because he has familiarity with the system that Chudz has implemented.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I mentioned Blackmon yesterday for this same topic's reasons, for our wideouts are either developing or aging.

A veteran player like Edwards could relieve Smitty but it has not been done since Moose. It seems you need to have someone just as passionate as Smitty, or it does not work. Not selfish but crazy to get along on the field. TE Shockey has passion and it worked. Keyshawn was selfish and it failed bad.

Perhaps Chad Johnson? he has personal history and has passion. He would get along with Smitty and help Cam.

If we pick up a wide receiver in the draft, he needs to be very comfortable in his abilities. Hence, a high pick rather a late one in the draft.

Jarrett, Colbert, dude from OSU that the raiders picked up a few years back all were later picks that did not work opposite Smitty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, he definitely showed flashes... But for example, in Houston, he was targeted a multitude of times and failed to come up with a single catch. And if you can't get ahead of Naanee except when he gets injured, I'm not impressed.

I don't see a great need for us to get a WR this yeaar, unless he's a return man. We have other areas that are more important that needs to be addressed first.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You may not have noticed, but we already added a receiver that had more receptions than Naanee/ LaFell last year. His name is Mike Tolbert and in the Turner/Chud system he will be more than just an outlet. We'll pound the ball with our three headed attack, throwing to the backs as part of moving the chains. Gettis/Smith will take the top off the defense daring them to put 8 in the box. Cam will hit them with a variety of 20+ yd passes on the outside. If the defense tries to take this away, Olsen/Barnidge will beat them down the middle.

Rivera is making a concerted effort to upgrade the special teams and adding a KO/P returner is more valuable IMO. If he happens to be a WR, so be it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fail, LaFell started over Legetron at the end of the season and he went hard in the clutch. We have no third this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are people really defending AE? He wasn't on the field much because he didn't earn none of his damn TIME! Lafell EARNED the #2 position. Jesus christ, I'll be glad when we cut him, worst decision ever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They are talking about Braylon Edwards, good lord, read the thread before you freak out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites