18 replies to this topic

[EasternJ]

Not sure if anyone saw this -- or made mention of it yesterday.....

http://www.cbssports...r-getting-to-53

[Cary Kollins]

I really hope we don't cut Gettis.

[JawnyBlaze]

lol yea right they're going to cut Barnidge. Don't think so.

[rayzor]

looks about right to me except i would keep reggie smith and cut pugh. i hope they don't have to IR hogan.

i'm not sure about cutting barnidge instead of one of the other two, either. barney will be one of the TEs.

[Cary Kollins]

Yeah that catch he made last week alone should keep him on the team.

[Ivan The Awesome]

lol @ keeping armanti.

[SetfreexX]

QB-Cam, Derek, Jimmy
HB-Williams, Stewrart, Poole (We will have a third back on the roster, even if just as insurance)
FB-Tolbert
WR-Smith, LaFell, Murphy, Pilares, Adams, ??? (agree Gettis to PUP if not back by final game)
TE-Olsen, Barnidge (we have to have a back-up receiving TE), Harstock
OL-Gross, Silatolu, Kalil, Hangartner, Bell, Cambell. Williams, Pollack

NT-Edwards, Fua, Kearse
UT-McClain, Neblett
LB-Beason, Kuechly, Anderson, Senn, Phillips, WIlliams, Onatulu, Davis
DB-Gamble, Norman, Munnerlyn, Butler, Thomas (Hogan PUP)
FS-Nakamura, Martin
SS-Godfrey, Smith

K-Medlock
P-Nortman
KR-Pilares
PR-Adams
LS-Jansen

I just can't see us keeping a guy like Armanti around, Seyi maybe as the 6th WR until Gettis is fully recovered. During Gettis' rookie year he showed more play-making ability vs LaFell who didn't really begin to 'flash' until last season. With that being said I think the last spot is his as we'll feature mainly 3 WR sets. I don't see Hogan back on IR again, a lot were really excited with what he could bring and he looked good in his limited time last season (HOU). Just wondering why the set backs...? I'll take the vets at the safety spots over Pugh, Nelson, and Campbell. Also Medlock over Mare, we ALREADY know/knew Mare wasn't clutch, so why move forward with him since it seems Medlock has better range on his FG's even though he hasn't proved his worth in the NFL yet, but hoping he will.

As far as Nakamura at starting FS my concern is how will he hold up in coverage as the deep safety at 5'10....I know he's a surer tackler than Martin but that's the only concern, maybe he'll see time in the box with Godfrey over the top in known passing situations.

[Murph]

Armanti in and Barnridge out are the only two mistakes that are obvious. The rest is reasonable.

[NCBlu]

If David Gettis starts the season on PUP I would bet that they keep Armanti Edwards as the 6th wr, but based on play if he would get cut or not when Gettis come back in 6-8 weeks.. I sure dont want Seyi Ajirotutu to make it if Gettis is not ready..

[EasternJ]

With Gettis not practicing and two injuries to recover from, it could be quite a while before he was available to play--- much less make an impact. As good as he looked before the ACL, it's certainly not a lock that he'll look near as good when/if he makes it back. Of course, you'd hate to have him dropped and look good somewhere else in a few months......

[MadHatter]

Ones that I do not agree with:

1. Do not think there is any chance Barnidge gets cut
2. Not sure that we only carry Williams, Stew, and Tolbert. I think one of the other guys makes it.
3. Don't know much about Bryant Browning (OL). Surprised to see him stay and Pollack go.
4. Would hate to see Gettis and Hogan not make it....but if they can't get on the field damn soon I think it is a real possibility.
5. I would not keep Clausen. I would rather see Armanti play QB in a pinch than ever see Clausen on the field. He is just that bad.

[MadHatter]

If David Gettis starts the season on PUP I would bet that they keep Armanti Edwards as the 6th wr, but based on play if he would get cut or not when Gettis come back in 6-8 weeks.. I sure dont want Seyi Ajirotutu to make it if Gettis is not ready..

Agree.

[rayzor]

Ones that I do not agree with:

1. Do not think there is any chance Barnidge gets cut
2. Not sure that we only carry Williams, Stew, and Tolbert. I think one of the other guys makes it.
3. Don't know much about Bryant Browning (OL). Surprised to see him stay and Pollack go.
4. Would hate to see Gettis and Hogan not make it....but if they can't get on the field damn soon I think it is a real possibility.
5. I would not keep Clausen. I would rather see Armanti play QB in a pinch than ever see Clausen on the field. He is just that bad.

i think we'd be more than OK with just those 3 RBs. whoever they can keep on the pup between vaughn and poole they probably will just in case. if they do keep one of those two around, their play on STs will be the deciding factor.

as far as gettis and hogan...i don't see a problem keeping either of them around on the PUP list. see how the other guys at their positions work out and if gettis or hogan would be an upgrade at either spot then activate them. we might benefit from having a couple fresh options out there at that point in the season. they might come in handy and make a late season push more successful.

[MadHatter]

i think we'd be more than OK with just those 3 RBs. whoever they can keep on the pup between vaughn and poole they probably will just in case. if they do keep one of those two around, their play on STs will be the deciding factor.

as far as gettis and hogan...i don't see a problem keeping either of them around on the PUP list. see how the other guys at their positions work out and if gettis or hogan would be an upgrade at either spot then activate them. we might benefit from having a couple fresh options out there at that point in the season. they might come in handy and make a late season push more successful.

Given the injuries we have had at RB over the past few seasons, I definitely could see 4 making it. However, I agree with you that only keeping 3 is a real possibility....as Tolbert can play either RB or FB.

[lineal89]

I hope Gettis can get back really soon or we may see Tutu or even Edwards make if Gettis has to be put on IR again. I haven't heard anything about Bryant.