44 replies to this topic

[Smitty Is Our Savior]

Sorry if the title is misleading, but I missed tonight's game and I'd like to see what yall have to say about who played well and who underperformed tonight.

Who you think jumped who in the depth chart too, if you don't mind.

Thanks!!

[SZ James]

Winners: The Steelers

Losers: The Panthers

[Tarheels23]

Winners: Murphy, Pilares, Smith, Bryant, Nortman, Green, RJ Stanford, Clausen, Jason Williams, Reggie Smith

Losers: Tutu, Armanti, Van Bergen, Medlock, Senn

Although most of you won't, I added Reggie Smith to the winners list. I know he got beat for the TD, but he was in good position, and seems to play the ball pretty well. I do think he's more of a free safety though.

[megadeth078]

Losers:

Medlock
Medlock
Medlock
Medlock
Medlock
Medlock
Medlock

Only aspect of this game that mattered in any way, and he sh*t the bed.

[TruCatzFan]

Winners: The Carolina Panthers... No serious injuries, and for the first time in a very long time we are going into the regular season HEALTHY!!!

[Jackofalltrades]

Winners: Murphy, Pilares, Smith, Bryant, Nortman, Green, RJ Stanford, Clausen, Jason Williams, Reggie Smith

Losers: Tutu, Armanti, Van Bergen, Medlock, Senn

Although most of you won't, I added Reggie Smith to the winners list. I know he got beat, but he was in good position, and seems to play the ball pretty well. I do think he's more of a free safety though.

This.

I'd also add Keiser and Alexander to the winners and Brian Murphy to the PHUCK YOU!!!! list.

[Chaos]

Medlock did kick a few kick offs out of the endzone though, but he's got to calm down on FG's. Although I guess if you're looking for a choke artist, keep the one that doesn't cost $12M

[XClown1986]

Winners: Armond Smith, Tauren Poole, Jason Phillips, Jason Williams, Thomas Keiser, Frank Alexander, Reggie Smith, RJ Stanford, Lamont Bryant, Jared Green, Sione Fua, Terrell McClain (I thought he looked explosive at times), Kealoha Pilares, DJ Campbell, Brad Nortman

Losers: Justin Medlock, Joe Adams, Jordan Pugh, Josh Thomas, Darius Butler, Armanti Edwards

[Irv]

Winners
Armond Smith
Tauren Poole
Jimmy Clausen
Louis Murphy
(Partially) armanti edwards

Losers
TuTu
Medlock
Special Teams

[Chaos]

Tutu better be the first one cut. For the opportunities he's been afforded, he has done diddly poo with them. Nothing.

[jasonluckydog]

Winners: Clausen-Newton-RNC-Gamecocks-Dan BB#14-Your mom-Keiser-My mom-Clint Eastwood-Murphy

losers: Armanti-Brittney BB#14-Vanderbilt-S/T-Brian Murphy-Obama-Honey Boo Boo-TuTu

[WolfpackRob]

Winners: Clausen-Newton-RNC-Gamecocks-Dan BB#14-Your mom-Keiser-My mom-Clint Eastwood-Murphy

losers: Armanti-Brittney BB#14-Vanderbilt-S/T-Brian Murphy-Obama-Honey Boo Boo-TuTu

I was DVRing the gamecock game...Thanks for the spoiler

[pilot2011]

winners: Murphy, Phillips, Poole/Smith, Stanford, Finley.

losers: toots, adams, barnidge, punt protection.

AE caught the passes that were catchable, looked comfortable catching punts in the redzone, and blocked well for the rb's... Still doesn't have the killer mentality that it will take to be successful (ala going up and snatching that fade in the endzone for the td) as of right now, but showed enough to make the squad over toots magoots.

[jasonluckydog]

I was DVRing the gamecock game...Thanks for the spoiler

That game ended 3 hours ago...Half the board here is Gamecock fans. My bad then,,,I hope I didnt spoil Big Brother for you as well.

[Jackofalltrades]

I agree about AE. I'm not an App or Armanti homer, but he did show enough for me to get a last chance. We got to see some of that athleticism tonight but he still has to learn the nuances of the position.

I won't be upset if they hang on to him, the problem is he's got more competition than the last two seasons and I'm really interested in Green and Bryant.