Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

fieryprophet

2012 Team Captains Announced

66 posts in this topic

Gross and smith were both on our superbowl team and both rank higher at their position than cam. Also they are both integral for Cam's success. No offense but Cam needs those guys more than they need Cam.

I beg to differ. They're great. But they need Cam just as much if not more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

as a joke, right?

Why would Cam getting a C be a joke. I get why they did it....no bigge. My preference would have simply been Gross and Cam.

Smith is an awesome WR. His behavior has been spotty overall. Rather Cam wear it personally now that our future is here with a year under his belt.

a joke would be thinking our franchise QB isn't worthy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why would Cam getting a C be a joke. I get why they did it....no bigge. My preference would have simply been Gross and Cam.

Smith is an awesome WR. His behavior has been spotty overall. Rather Cam wear it personally now that our future is here with a year under his belt.

a joke would be thinking our franchise QB isn't worthy.

Cam isn't even close to being mature yet. He still has a lot to learn about the game. Giving him a C would be a counter-intuitive way of making him grow. It would probably backfire. Nothing worse than a kid who thinks he's accomplished/learned enough already. You must spoil your kids. Plus, we're talking about Smitty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gross and smith were both on our superbowl team and both rank higher at their position than cam. Also they are both integral for Cam's success. No offense but Cam needs those guys more than they need Cam.

Well, I don't want to hijack this thread....

But Cam is the most irreplaceable guy on this O.....not Smith or Gross. Losing Cam is a much bigger blow than either of those 2. I would put Smitty as #2 in that conversation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, I don't want to hijack this thread....

But Cam is the most irreplaceable guy on this O.....not Smith or Gross. Losing Cam is a much bigger blow than either of those 2. I would put Smitty as #2 in that conversation.

Team captains are not about who is the best athlete on the team....or who is more irreplacable on teh team. Team captains are typically the elder statesmen on the team that helps the team keep its focus....keeps the locker room at peace...etc. You need those guys that have been aroudn and udnerstand what it takes in the NFL for multiple seasons....not typically a rookie.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cam isn't even close to being mature yet. He still has a lot to learn about the game. Giving him a C would be a counter-intuitive way of making him grow up. It would probably backfire. Nothing worse than a kid who thinks he's accomplished/learned enough already. You must spoil your kids. Plus, we're talking about Smitty.

why bring maturity into this....when was the last time Smith had 2 back to back "mature" seasons.

LOL, you equate me personally thinking the best player should get a C to mean I spoil my son?

If you have followed Cam....a patch isn't going to spoil him or make him think he has arrived.

No need to get panties in a bunch. I said I get it....just my personal preference was a little different. Only on the huddle will a tiny comment be viewed as the ultimate insult.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Team captains are not about who is the best athlete on the team....or who is more irreplacable on teh team. Team captains are typically the elder statesmen on the team that helps the team keep its focus....keeps the locker room at peace...etc. You need those guys that have been aroudn and udnerstand what it takes in the NFL for multiple seasons....not typically a rookie.

I didn't realize Cam was a rookie?

Why was Beason a captain in 2008?

Like I said, no biggie....that would have just been my preference.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

why bring maturity into this....when was the last time Smith had 2 back to back "mature" seasons.

LOL, you equate me personally thinking the best player should get a C to mean I spoil my son?

If you have followed Cam....a patch isn't going to spoil him or make him think he has arrived.

No need to get panties in a bunch. I said I get it....just my personal preference was a little different. Only on the huddle will a tiny comment be viewed as the ultimate insult.

?

Did you completely misinterpret the tone of my post? You must have. Read it again. This time don't picture the imaginary capslock (and ignore my avatar lol). Good lord, man. I thought we were just having a discussion here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't we all agree that we have more Captain-worthy players than we have badges to hand out? I have no problem with the choices, and I can bet that Cam looks up to and respects Steve Smith and Jordan Gross a hell of a lot more than the other way around. Not that the vets don't respect Cam, I believe they do because he is humble, but Cam has made it clear how much he looks up to the elder statesmen who have proven their worth in this league for many years.

Maybe Cam can be hall monitor or line leader if people feel he needs an accolade, but to be serious, Cam is a sharp individual and knows where his bread is buttered - the offensive line and his perennial pro bowl WR.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites