21 replies to this topic

[Dxterity]

"Steve smith has a Bum knee right now...how effective do you think he's gonna be? and the last time I Checked comparing Cam to Eli is like comparing a Candle to the Sun....nuff said"




http://boards.giants...killed-tomorrow

[nosuchthingasapanther]

eli > cam

[Dxterity]

eli > cam

The first part was what made me giggle. Eli is a great QB with two Superbowl MVP's. Respect.

[Cj72]

Eli is to streaky for my taste. Excluding last year he is either going to throw for tons of yards or throw tons of ints

[mwright350]

I wouldn't bash Eli. The man has a knack for 4th qtr heroics and he's helmed that team to two suberbowl titles in his career so far. One while being last in the league in rushing is a pretty big plus in his favor.

I'm not saying I'd rather have him...but he's certainly got the resume to deserve respect.

[nctarheel0619]

I love Cam better then the next guy. But to think he's better then Eli is blasphemous.

[I Registered To Post This]

wow so the giants are going on the road to play a team that's perceived as something of a mismatch due to injuries and other factors.

guys i just can't think of a time when the giants have succeeded under these circumstances before

[Dxterity]

I love Cam better then the next guy. But to think he's better then Eli is blasphemous.

I never said he was better... Read my second post.

[nctarheel0619]

I never said he was better... Read my second post.

Oh no, I know you wouldn't think that. There are some other Huddle members that think he is though. *cough* BWood *cough*

[Chaos]

Where's the guy who wouldn't stop Eli if he tried to rape him tho?

[Iceberg Slim]

interesting reading their board, not a lot of homers. Surprisingly fair assessments

[88 Bronco]

My only issue with Eli goes back to when he was drafted.

[Jesse]

interesting reading their board, not a lot of homers. Surprisingly fair assessments

I also came across that. A panther fan posted in their telling our side and 5/6 of the posts said "nice post. " I was baffled of how shitty that made our board and fans sound.

[panthers55]

I also came across that. A panther fan posted in their telling our side and 5/6 of the posts said "nice post. " I was baffled of how shitty that made our board and fans sound.

Lets not paint the whole message board with that broad brush.

[Johnny Rockets]

interesting reading their board, not a lot of homers. Surprisingly fair assessments

Even as an Eagles fan, I have never had a bad football conversation with a Giants fan and I have had plenty of them. Hell, I'd rather talk football with a Giant's fan than most Eagle fans. Of course there are plenty of exceptions and I could change my opinion after dealing with them tonight but they are a very knowledgable fan base for the most part.