19 replies to this topic

[ReadyorNot]

I truly believe this guy is an egomaniac and thinks he can put in any offense and it will work, or that he will revolutionize the NFL offense as we know it so he can add it to his resume. He's got his head too far up his ass and he's ruining Cam's development in the process, and he's wasting a dangerous backfield.

[Rubi]

Our offense should be based around what we can do with our backfield....

Even with that being said...DWill looks old and worn down now...not sure why we haven't been starting Stewart by now and sprinkling in a little bowling ball action w Tolbert...

Good way to form an identity and take pressure off Cam

[Daddy Uncle]

He'll probably be the next HC of the Panthers once Rivera is fired

[the_philosopher]

I agree with the OP. After watching the Bucs game, I suspected that Chud's overly "cute" gameplan was a result of his being ticked off about not getting a head coaching job after his breakout year in 2011. So he decided to show the league how much smarter he was than everyone else by designing an offense that no one else was doing. I imagine in his mind, no one else was doing it because no on else was smart enough to design it, but in reality, I suspect no one else designed it because it's unlikely to work consistently against solid NFL defenses.

[Jrock88]

i dunno what chud is trying to do, its getting ridiculous.

and how is rivera allowing this crap to continue... i thought he was an old school, smash mouth kind of guy. yet he allows chud to run our offense like we're in the fuging SEC. really losing faith in this staff

[Icege]

I have no idea why people assume through play selection that somebody is an arrogant jackass looking to stick it to everybody else doubting their genius.

[mjligon]

I don't understand how anyone with half a brain would change anything about the offense we ran last year.

[the_philosopher]

I have no idea why people assume through play selection that somebody is an arrogant jackass looking to stick it to everybody else doubting their genius.

Fair enough. I give myself permission to be a bit more irrational than usual when it comes to my Panthers hobby. But it is true that ego is prominent in professional sports (for good reason), and that professional rejections by one's peers tend to hurt egos. And then there's the question as to why someone (whose ego was likely hurt) would revamp a darn good offense? One not too irrational answer, on my view, is that he's trying to prove just how smart he is.

[rayzor]

it could be. wouldn't upset me as much as the thought did last year.

he's not disciplined at all in his playcalling. not sure who i'd want to replace him with.

[mwright350]

I don't think it has anything at all to do with him wanting an HC job.

I think he saw how well the option plays worked last year when we ran them as a tool in a our offense and thought they would work just as well as our primary offense. Basically I think he recognized the need to evolve in this league but did it in the wrong way.

I also don't think we're going to see any major schematic changes in the offense mid-season, whether he's got an ego or not, because installing a different offense in the middle of the season would be terrible. The best chance we have to see schematic changes is during the bye week...minor ones. And we might. But don't count on it.

[Peppers90 NC]

this very weak theory has never entered my mind

[Matthias]

If Chud was going to take a college scheme and try to mold it to the nfl, I wish he would have took a few pages out of the West Virginia offense.

[mwright350]

I'd rather he didn't try to mold anyone's college offense into the NFL.

College offenses prey on the extreme mismatches that future NFL players have over players who will never play anything meaningful after college.

The NFL is not rife with these same mismatches

[Panthro]

Isn't that what any coordinator wants outside of Dick LeBeau?

[redbuddha]

Good news - Chud has basically eliminated any chance of him getting a head coaching job.
Bad news - Chud has basically eliminated any chance of him getting a head coaching job.