60 replies to this topic

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

http://sportsillustr...l?sct=cf_t11_a1

Very good SI article on him. Supposidly Bill Bellicheck picked his brain before flying over to london and dropping 45 points on the Rams (who have a pretty good defense) and has high respect for Kelly.

Kelly is the most organized has-his-poo-together coach people have seen in a long time. He's certainly a reverse from Rivera, that's for sure.

Who else in intrigued by this guy?

[TruCatzFan]

Who wouldn't be intrigued by anyone not Named Rivera at this point?

[carolina-chuck]

Would love him.

[La Pantera]

I'm intrigued by him...I also would be concerned about his transition to the NFL. Could be a huge risk/reward hire.

[Peppers90 NC]

i vote for his consideration

[JawnyBlaze]

As long as the man has the personality and people skills to relate to grown men and not just the domineering way of handling kids, I don't see there being much of a problem for college coaches transitioning to the NFL. It seems like it'd be less of a leap than from NFL coordinator (where all you handle is gameplanning and playcalling) to HC. Coordinators have to learn to lead, how to manage a whole team, how to manage game time split second decisions, all these things are things college coaches have already learned. That's the reason I'd much rather get a retread NFL HC or a college HC than a coordinator.

[TonyN]

Not no, but Hell No.

His success has been based almost totally on a tweaked version of the read option offense that will never work at the NFL level. Never. How will he adjust? Who knows?

You guys love the read option so much??? LOL

Strike one.

He seems almost completely indifferent to what occurs on the defensive side of the ball, so he will have to be coupled with a top defensive guy. Even as we speak, his always suspect defense is getting gashed by USC...This is Chip Kelly's BEST defense at Oregon. They are 35th in the FBS....and this after playing a weak schedule.

Strike two.

The guy has no NFL experience. Zero. NADA. NONE. ZILTCHERINO.

Not as a Head Coach, assistant, player or even ball boy.

Basically you are crossing your fingers and hoping Chip Kelly is Jimmy Johnson. I believe Jimmy Johnson is the only college head coach to move to the NFL and win a Superbowl with no NFL experience. And Johnson went to Dallas after appearing in two national championship games (winning one), in 5 years at Miami. All while running a sophisticated Pro-style offense.

Strike three.

[TruCatzFan]

Btw, if there's ANY chance whatsoever that he's the reason we go to all Black Uni's then I'm ALL IN!

[Cline]

No college coaches.

/thread

[Bj-Monster23]

Chip Kelly has been brought up a lot on this board. I like the guy but I don't know if he will want to make that transition to the NFL.

[Lumps]

JR will not bring in a college coach and he won't bring in a big name, he will bring in a highly successful coridinator who deserves a chance, deserves a promotion, which RIvera did. Unfortunatley it seems he did not work out. I still see JR doing the same thing, promoting a successful defensive corinator. At least that is what he says he prefers doing.

[magnus]

yes, but it's risky.
I do think the spread would be fine in the NFL, many teams use a lot from it. But, too much option is gimmicky.

Being an established head coach in college means paying up big to get him, and you have to hope he can bring his DC. You won't get his OC, he's the heir apparent at Oregon; and you definitely want to put as many pro assistants under him as you can.

But, absolutely he's interesting. He's lost somewhere around 4 games in the last 3 years. That type thing gets infectious.

[Jackofalltrades]

I'd take Saban before Kelly.

I don't believe in gimmick offenses and his recruiting prowess means nothing in the NFL.

I don't want any college coaches other than those using it as a short term stepping stone, like Harbaugh did. Actually, if I was forced to choose a college coach the Stanford guy is the one I'd pick.

[TruCatzFan]

JR will not bring in a college coach and he won't bring in a big name, he will bring in a highly successful coridinator who deserves a chance, deserves a promotion, which RIvera did. Unfortunatley it seems he did not work out. I still see JR doing the same thing, promoting a successful defensive corinator. At least that is what he says he prefers doing.

I get what you're saying... But the man is running out of time, which leads me to believe that he's desperate and will do whatever is necessary to win in the very immediate future. I say he does go after a big name, and a proven one at that. I do however see a BIG changeover in HC's across the League during the offseason which will make it more difficult.
Here's the teams I think will be looking for a HC after the season:
KC
Philly
Carolina
Cleveland (New GM)
Possibly Jacksonville
And maybe others... It will make it a little more difficult to get who we want because of the attrition across the League imo

Speaking of which.... Do coaches' salaries go against the cap? Probably a dumb question, but I don't think that they do.

[TruCatzFan]

I'd take Saban before Kelly.

I don't believe in gimmick offenses and his recruiting prowess means nothing in the NFL.

You'd take Saban after what he did to Miami? I get why you'd want him as a coach, but in my mind he is not to be trusted ever again... Period!