74 replies to this topic

[Mr. Scot]

I seriously doubt the JR will allow any GM to part ways with Smith. This is Steve Smiths team to leave.

If Richardson is going to overrule his decisions, what's the point of having a new GM?

Nobody worth having is going to want the job if they know they're gonna be second guessed.

[SZ James]

Draft Cam - before it was cool to say

[citation needed]

Draft Luke bc we can't trust Beason and company to all be back

[citation needed]

Don't sign all these RBs bc we won't give them touches to justify it

[citation needed]

Chud is overrated and nothing like what is being pimped- last season when people wanted him as our HC

[citation needed]

I typically get the, "CRA, you are an idiot" for such thoughts......

[citation needed]

OP is an idiot until proven otherwise

[pantherclaw]

He could be the best slot receiver in the game.

Problem.is we don't have the talent at the position that would allow him to slide into the slot.

Get that talent, and steve smith would continue being one of the most feared receivers in the game.

[CRA]

If Richardson is going to overrule his decisions, what's the point of having a new GM?

Will be interesting.....Cam being another example.

Most new GMs/coaches in recent history have brought in a new QB within 3 years pending the one they inherited hasn't won a Superbowl. Richardson has claimed Newton is his last.

What if the new coach was to run a NFL spread like Rodgers, Brady or Brees do.....where the emphasis is on spreading it out and carving up teams? Cam won't ever fit that mold.

[Bwood]

I can determine pretty much every boom or bust draft prospect season after season.

Let's run the front office CRA.

[CRA]

I can determine pretty much every boom or bust draft prospect season after season.

Let's run the front office CRA.

I have a Clemson bias....so my team would suck as they all prove me wrong time and time again. Also would skip over Clowney in a couple years bc I hate the Gamecocks.....so I don't think I would excel.

[Wine&Cheese]

Draft Cam - before it was cool to say
Draft Luke bc we can't trust Beason and company to all be back
Don't sign all these RBs bc we won't give them touches to justify it
Chud is overrated and nothing like what is being pimped- last season when people wanted him as our HC

I typically get the, "CRA, you are an idiot" for such thoughts......

We should trade Smith or force him to retire after this year. Greatest Panther to date....but his time has run its course. He is one of MANY big moves we must start making. We need to move forward....I think as this season progresses that will become more clear. Bash away bc I know the Smitty man love is off the charts.....but his era is over and that era still holding on is one of several big problems IMO.

SO you are saying the eventhough several teams contacted us to see if he was available, we should force him to retire if we cant trade him (for what we see as fair value)?

...You dont think we can use him ANYWHERE on the field? LMAO!

Thank God you will never be a GM!

[Raskle]

If Richardson is going to overrule his decisions, what's the point of having a new GM?

Nobody worth having is going to want the job if they know they're gonna be second guessed.

That kind of explains the whole Hurney for ten years fiasco..... just sayin'

[CRA]

SO you are saying the eventhough several teams contacted us to see if he was available, we should force him to retire if we cant trade him (for what we see as fair value)?

...You dont think we can use him ANYWHERE on the field? LMAO!

Thank God you will never be a GM!

Yes.

And

Yes, you could use him.....but he still will bring his old era issues with him. Not a talent issue about everything else he brings to the table and impact it has on a franchise rebuilding. He isn't Jerry Rice and again I am not talking talent.

look at the last 3 years......2010, 2011, and 2012. At his age, he should be a rock......far from that in 2010 and 2012. When the going gets tough, he makes it tougher too often.

Lots of teams have parted with guys who still had the raw talent to contribute...

[La Pantera]

Need to find his replacement this draft, not cut him. There's not a WR in the draft that's going to come in and take the #1 spot. No Aj Green in this draft. But there are a bunch of guys who could after a year under their belt. Smitty NEEDS slot duty.

[Wine&Cheese]

I dont disagree with trading him but we cant move him anywhere until he have some kind of replacement. We have consistently proven that we cant draft and develop a guy into a #1. We must acquire a guy we know can play in FA.

[CRA]

I dont disagree with trading him but we cant move him anywhere until he have some kind of replacement. We have consistently proven that we cant draft and develop a guy into a #1. We must acquire a guy we know can play in FA.

Someone like Mike Wallace would be nice

[Priapism]

We should trade Smith or force him to retire after this year. Greatest Panther to date....but his time has run its course. He is one of MANY big moves we must start making. We need to move forward....I think as this season progresses that will become more clear. Bash away bc I know the Smitty man love is off the charts.....but his era is over and that era still holding on is one of several big problems IMO.

It's unpopular to to say things like this because we have an emotinoal attatchement to Smitty, a kinship if you will, an a afinity.

However, if I step outside of the emotional attatchement I agree with you. For the greater good of the Panthers team, it would probably be the something to seriously consider in regards to the future of this franchise.

Like many of you I don't ever want to see Smith go, I don't like it, it really is a sad thought. Whether we like it or not, that day is eventually coming. So I suppose we need to ask ourselves, when? When is it a time to have a legitimate discussion? Now?
I'm not sure but if I want to see this team that I love suceed in the future, it's something I am willing to lay on the table for discussion.

[Mr. Scot]

Will be interesting.....Cam being another example.

Most new GMs/coaches in recent history have brought in a new QB within 3 years pending the one they inherited hasn't won a Superbowl. Richardson has claimed Newton is his last.

What if the new coach was to run a NFL spread like Rodgers, Brady or Brees do.....where the emphasis is on spreading it out and carving up teams? Cam won't ever fit that mold.

It's a possibility. A remote one, but a real one.

Pretty sure nobody saw the Jay Cutler trade coming.

[TheRed]

You lost me at Steve Smith. I'm not ready for that poo yet. You can't make me!