Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Panthro

The Anti-Walmart

236 posts in this topic

i said "leverage their labor" since, you know, labor is in fact a commodity

Their "labor" has no leverage. It's an unskilled job. At least so far as most retailers are concerned. If anyone can do what you are doing you have no leverage.

also it's not very easy to leverage your labor when you're a wage slave. minimum wage isn't a living wage.

Not arguing that. I would like to see retailers hold their employee's to higher standards of work/customer service/hell hygiene in some places, and by doing such increase the value of their employee's and pay them higher hourly wages. See: CostCo. Store is always clean, workers are friendly, workers don't look like meth heads, workers are knowledgeable, etc. Usually none of those things apply to your average Wally World worker.

the point is, i don't see any consistency when you can say both "yeah sure they should be able to fight for higher wages" and "they should just stop bitching about working on holidays because they knew what they were getting into"

These are two completely different things. My wife is a heart surgery nurse. She was on call "working" all Thanksgiving and the following weekend. It's part of the job. If you work retail, especially Walmart and the like, expect to work some Holiday time that 9-5'ers use to shop for presents and Black Friday deals.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bringing the conversation back to what it should be focused on- Costco's food is the poo. Their spanish rice and frozen chicken thighs are super easy and tasty, and the sliced peaches they sell in the clear jars are like crack

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i said "leverage their labor" since, you know, labor is in fact a commodity

also it's not very easy to leverage your labor when you're a wage slave. minimum wage isn't a living wage.

the point is, i don't see any consistency when you can say both "yeah sure they should be able to fight for higher wages" and "they should just stop bitching about working on holidays because they knew what they were getting into"

I guess I just don't get where you're going with that...

If you work in retail, holidays are the biggest selling times of the year... wanting higher wages doesn't have anything to do with working the hours you have to work to perform your job.

I mean, you can fight for not working holidays all you want... but if the store you work at is open on holidays, um... you gotta work if you want that particular job.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

287px-Image_of_Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fire_on_March_25_-_1911.jpg

trianglecov1.jpg

oh look here's some people who knew what they were getting into

I'm trying to have a fairly hostility free discussion here.

Why would you compare people jumping out of a burning factory to their deaths to people working on Thanksgiving?

Not only is that ignorant, it's incredibly insulting to those who died by comparing their lives to having to go to work when you don't want to.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm trying to have a fairly hostility free discussion here.

Why would you compare people jumping out of a burning factory to their deaths to people working on Thanksgiving?

Not only is that ignorant, it's incredibly insulting to those who died by comparing their lives to having to go to work when you don't want to.

but they knew what they were signing up for when they took the job

the point is, that's been the same argument against workers rights since forever

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess I just don't get where you're going with that...

If you work in retail, holidays are the biggest selling times of the year... wanting higher wages doesn't have anything to do with working the hours you have to work to perform your job.

I mean, you can fight for not working holidays all you want... but if the store you work at is open on holidays, um... you gotta work if you want that particular job.

yes i'm sure people are just going to forego purchasing their shitty tvs if walmart is closed on thanksgiving day

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Their "labor" has no leverage. It's an unskilled job. At least so far as most retailers are concerned. If anyone can do what you are doing you have no leverage.

this isn't remotely true. it has nothing to do with whether or not anyone can do it, and more to do with the willingness of those people to do it, as well as the ability of wage slaves to protest it

i'd agree that they have little leverage, but only because their only alternative is starving to death or becoming one of those alleged "parasites"

Not arguing that. I would like to see retailers hold their employee's to higher standards of work/customer service/hell hygiene in some places, and by doing such increase the value of their employee's and pay them higher hourly wages. See: CostCo. Store is always clean, workers are friendly, workers don't look like meth heads, workers are knowledgeable, etc. Usually none of those things apply to your average Wally World worker.

i'm pretty sure higher wages came first. imagine that, costco pays its employees a living wage and, well, they value their job! this is like, the least surprising thing ever!

These are two completely different things. My wife is a heart surgery nurse. She was on call "working" all Thanksgiving and the following weekend. It's part of the job. If you work retail, especially Walmart and the like, expect to work some Holiday time that 9-5'ers use to shop for presents and Black Friday deals.

sorry but people need heart surgery more than they need a shitty tv

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes i'm sure people are just going to forego purchasing their shitty tvs if walmart is closed on thanksgiving day

Gas stations are open, McDonalds is open, my gym was open, CVS and Walgreens were open... people still need to buy poo on holidays and people that get jobs at those places know that when they hire on. Still not seeing the problem.

When I hire someone, one of the things I give them is a list of holidays and how many personal days they get... they know up front what the expectations are... and I also tell them that if we have a project due, holidays can be shifted and you may be expected to work those times...

It'd be different if policies changed without notification, but it's pretty standard stuff we're talking about...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

but they knew what they were signing up for when they took the job

the point is, that's been the same argument against workers rights since forever

Walmart is not locking it's doors with chains.

It is not providing similarly unsafe working conditions.

Many of the folks in your example might have not realized the danger the flammable materials presented. Nor ,at the time, might not of realized how dangerous the work they were doing at the time.

Also, they burned to death, not miss the Pats/Jets game, their bodies were on fire or they were jumping out of windows.

Walmart/Retailers are asking their employees to come to work at a prime shopping time.

The two examples have nothing in common.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Walmart is not locking it's doors with chains.

It is not providing similarly unsafe working conditions.

Many of the folks in your example might have not realized the danger the flammable materials presented. Nor ,at the time, might not of realized how dangerous the work they were doing at the time.

Also, they burned to death, not miss the Pats/Jets game, their bodies were on fire or they were jumping out of windows.

Walmart/Retailers are asking their employees to come to work at a prime shopping time.

The two examples have nothing in common.

i thought friday was the prime shopping time? oh wait this year all of the retailers decided to convince people that thursday was the day to buy their worthless poo

e: btw congrats on your poo tv

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, they burned to death, not miss the Pats/Jets game, their bodies were on fire or they were jumping out of windows.

that almost sounds preferable to the jets/pats game.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites