190 replies to this topic

[nctarheel0619]

Knowing what you guys know now. Who would you choose if you could? I'm just curious what you guys pick and reasons would be. I know I'll probably get reamed for this. But oh well. In before gif approved and all that stuff. My pick? Cam still. I'm a homer but I think with the right coaching and scheme he can excel more than Luck. I think Bob will get hurt in the NFL eventually. He's too damn small.

[Daddy Uncle]

Cam Newton is my QB. fug all the others

[CatMan72]

Cam.

[nctarheel0619]

I said reasons why. Not one word answers.

[BBQ&Beer]

As things are now, Cam. Mainly due to his durability once flushed from the pocket.

[K9]

This will surely get a non-partisan answer from most people here....

I really wanted Luck to come out two years ago and I definitely favored him over Cam. But Cam is our QB and I will support him until he does something really stupid. His mobility and strength is what I find very unique about him.

[KillerKat]

Cam in a pro style offense is deadly

[nctarheel0619]

This will surely get a non-partisan answer from most people here....

I really wanted Luck to come out two years ago and I definitely favored him over Cam. But Cam is our QB and I will support him until he does something really stupid. His mobility and strength is what I find very unique about him.

Hopefully he can step up his accuracy. If he does that, skies the limit. That dude Bob Griffin takes a pounding. He won't last.

[lineal89]

I would chose Cam Newton! Granted, Luck and RG III both look good and have played well. But there is more to the comparison in my opinion. In my opinion: both the Colts, especially the Colts, and Redskins have established foundations. By foundations, I mean upper management above the HC. Thats where the house is built from, you start at the top and build down to the players. We need the right General Manager. That decision and that decision alone will make or break our team.

[RelaxImaPro]

I'd still take Cam, though I wouldn't be disappointed with any of them. To me Cam has the most upside out of any of them... He has all the physical tools you could hope to ask for, and he can make some beautiful throws when given the chance. Most of his problems this season have come from the offensive scheme we've been running and he's still shown glimpses of excellence. As far as his actual problems go, they're all very fixable simple mechanic issues like footwork... and those damn short passes sometimes. Once he gets that short-medium range accuracy down he's going to be fuging deadly.

It looks like a bright future in the NFL for quarterbacks though regardless. Should be a fun next decade and a half to watch.

[K9]

His accuracy is my biggest gripe, but he's been making some amazing throws the past couple of weeks.

Still needs to work on those overthrows...'specially for ole' Smith at 5'9

[nctarheel0619]

Good replies fellas. I hope both of you are right.

[Bj-Monster23]

A couple of years ago I wanted Luck. He didn't come out but that's fine. For the long term I'm taking Cam all day and all night.

[CardiacCats]

Honestly, Andrew Luck

I think we have a damn good QB on our hands that's going to bring us loads of success, but I have a feeling Luck is gonna be Montana/Manning/Marino-esque. Indy does not deserve him.

[nctarheel0619]

I asked this question partially because I went to The Panthers vs Broncos game a few weeks back. Everyone there I asked seemed to wish we had Luck instead. They were Panthers fans BTW.