Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

nctarheel0619

Who would you choose for the next 5 years? Russel Wilson, Cam Newton, Andrew Luck, or Ed from Good Burger Aka Bob Griffin

191 posts in this topic

Andrew Luck

Luck is younger even if only by months.

Luck is going to have more passing yards in his rookie year than Cam Newton.

Cam Newton had the advantage of running against defenses that were on a shortened offseason. This didn't help just Cam, but it helped many passers in the league. Evidence by having 4 or 5 guys last year hit 5k passing yards. This year there are 0 guys on pace to hit 5k. Stafford is on pace for something like 4992.

Andrew Luck has the most 300 yard passing games by any rookie ever. Cam had huge games to start the season and his passing stats got lower and lower by seasons end.

Andrew Luck and the Pro Style offense he runs is more sustainable in the NFL than read-option crap we try to run in Carolina.

Andrew Luck ALREADY makes those around him better.

Cam Newton helped the team with 4 more games than it did the previous season. His second year it looks like they may not win 6. We are in the running for the #1 pick again...

By comparison, Andrew Luck has lead his team to 2 more wins than Cam already in his rookie season. Hell, Cam Newton has 9 wins in his career to Andrew Luck's 8.

Andrew Luck set a more important record than passing yards. Andrew Luck's 8 wins are the most by a QB drafted #1 in the SB era in his rookie season.

I hate "potential" because few reach their full potential. Andrew Luck is a better QB in the NFL right now, than Cam is. Cam is amazing, but Luck is already one of the leagues best.

Cam has DW, JStew, Steve Smith, Ols, and LaFell to throw to or hand off to. Andrew Luck has Wayne and Hilton. Luck has made a bust of Donnie Avery look like a good WR.

Andrew Luck has 5 come from behind wins in his rookie year.

There is nothing wrong with liking Luck. RG3 throws too many short passes and is too small to run as much as he wants and already has a concussion this season. I think he will fall off in a few years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hate "potential" because few reach their full potential. Andrew Luck is a better QB in the NFL right now, than Cam is. Cam is amazing, but Luck is already one of the leagues best.

I would like to kow how you came to that conclusion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like to kow how you came to that conclusion

maybe it's the 55% completion percentage

maybe it's the league-leading 16 interceptions

or maybe it's

67278973-10120221.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm kinda mad they didn't interview bob griffins pimple too after the game. It looked like it had something to say

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cams' build, enthusiasm, swag

Wilsons' tenacity, drive

Lucks' clutch

RG3s' finesse

Take their strengths and combine them to make a dream qb phenom....

Also, thats the order in which I would call my favorites. Honestly,..each one of these guys have "it", Newton has more...way more imo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cams' build, enthusiasm, swag

Wilsons' tenacity, drive

Lucks' clutch

RG3s' finesse

Take their strengths and combine them to make a dream qb phenom....

Also, thats the order in which I would call my favorites. Honestly,..each one of these guys have "it", Newton has more...way more imo

Pretty useless QB unless he has some accuracy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cam, Dalton, Luck, Rg3, Wilson, but Wilson has impressed me more than any of them this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites