Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Who are your top 5 best players on the Panthers?

44 posts in this topic

Posted

Bottom 5:

1) Kris Mangum

2) Eric Shelton

3) Norberto Davidds-Garrido

4) Keyshawn Johnson

5) Todd Stuessie

Keyshawn Johnson.... hilarious.

Dude played 11 seasons in the NFL, his last In Carolina.

Averaged 74 receptions a year before coming to Carolina- had 70 the year he spent in Charlotte, as the #2 WR. How many #2's get 70 catches a season?

Averaged 975 yards per season before coming to Carolina- had 815 in his year with Panthers, again as a #2 WR. There are #1's out there who don't get 800 yards in a season

Averaged 6 TDs per season before he got to the Panthers- had 4 TDs in his season here.

...and his first 8 years in the league he was the #1 WR for his 4 years with the Jets and the next 4 with the Bucs.

All he did was produce in his 11th and final season in the NFL at the same level he produced his entire career.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

lol I forgot we had Keyshawn Johnson on the Panthers,he was our last big name FA signing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Not sure about the entire top 5 but with the way some fans are reacting to his benching, Josh Norman must be one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Bottom 5

Chris Weinke

Stefan LeFors

Randy Fasani

Jeff Lewis

JImmy Clausen

Weinke and Clausen on Jeff Lewis list.. ouch!

Even if you dislike both Weinke and Clausen, this is not nice, not nice at all !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Weinke and Clausen on Jeff Lewis list.. ouch!

Even if you dislike both Weinke and Clausen, this is not nice, not nice at all !

For a franchise that's only 18 years old, I was only trying to illustrate just how many QBs, bad QBs this team has been through... and there are more than just these 5.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Top 5

Cam

Kuechly

Smitty

Johnson

Kalil

Bottom 5

Nakamura

Godfrey

Fua

Armanti

Clausen :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Cam

Luke

Smitty

Davis

CJ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Keyshawn Johnson.... hilarious.

Dude played 11 seasons in the NFL, his last In Carolina.

Averaged 74 receptions a year before coming to Carolina- had 70 the year he spent in Charlotte, as the #2 WR. How many #2's get 70 catches a season?

Averaged 975 yards per season before coming to Carolina- had 815 in his year with Panthers, again as a #2 WR. There are #1's out there who don't get 800 yards in a season

Averaged 6 TDs per season before he got to the Panthers- had 4 TDs in his season here.

...and his first 8 years in the league he was the #1 WR for his 4 years with the Jets and the next 4 with the Bucs.

All he did was produce in his 11th and final season in the NFL at the same level he produced his entire career.

Ah, the old "but his stats say he was good" routine. He had a good career away from Charlotte, he made my bottom 5 list not because he couldn't play but because of the kind of player he was. Never liked the man, didnt want him here and he acted just like I thought he would and lasted about as long as i thought too.

Dwayne Jarrett come on Doooowwwnnnn!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I still have my Rod Rutherford Pro Bowl jersey

Props

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Ah, the old "but his stats say he was good" routine. He had a good career away from Charlotte, he made my bottom 5 list not because he couldn't play but because of the kind of player he was. Never liked the man, didnt want him here and he acted just like I thought he would and lasted about as long as i thought too.

Dwayne Jarrett come on Doooowwwnnnn!

What does "a good career away from Charlotte" mean, exactly? Given the fact he did the exact same thing in Charlotte he did everywhere else he played...

5 best or 5 worst players..... not your 5 best and worst friends or favorite guys. Key could play and he did- what else do you want?

Kobe Bryant is a complete jerk-off, too, but give him his props- he can play. Would he make your NBA list?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

5 best or 5 worst players..... not your 5 best and worst friends or favorite guys. Key could play and he did- what else do you want?

Kobe Bryant is a complete jerk-off, too, but give him his props- he can play. Would he make your NBA list?

Would Kobe make my NBA list? yep

Did Keyshawn make my 5 worst list? yep

How in the world those two people are comparable outside of being athletes is beyond me.

And to add to this i saw some funny names on some peoples responses and it made me think of my most hated ie: worst panthers, and after Kris Mangum who also "produced" in a panthers uniform as a blocker in fox's offense Meshawn was quick to follow.

And this, my easily offended friend, is the beauty of the interwebz. If you dont like my list, make your own. And i'll try really hard to give it some thought, no promises though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

cam,-superman

steve,-wolverine

olsen,-green arrow

kalil,-beast

hardy,-luke cage

johnson-war machine

,stewart-black panther

luke-batman

and the fans

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites