60 replies to this topic

[stirs]

http://ca.news.yahoo...-192855747.html


Holding these guys responsible for their patients actions.

Will they take the easy/safe route and just have folks committed?

Always being able to blame someone might have its consequences

[Panthro]

Not sure what HIPAA/doctor patient info states about that here

[Zod]

I love American Horror Story Asylum.

[Panthro]

I'd be for releasing non violent offenders (hippies) and using that money towards mental health facilities

[stirs]

Not sure what HIPAA/doctor patient info states about that here

Well, as we can see, it only takes one tragedy for current laws to be changed in France.

Here? Heck, we are looking at changing the constitution due to a tragedy. Would HIPPA laws never be subject to change if we found that Lanza himself had been seen several times by a professional who did nothing to protect the public?

Just debating the point

[Zod]

Here? Heck, we are looking at changing the constitution due to a tragedy. W

How so?

[stirs]

How so?

Zod? or Coy?

[Zod]

The second ammendment calls for regulation, no?

[stirs]

Gun laws, more gun laws, regulations, more regulations.

Criminal bypasses all and kills legal owner for their guns. Answer? More gun laws

[Inimicus]

HIPPA doesn't get in the way of this. Mental Health professionals are what is referred to as "mandatory reporters" that is to say that they are required to break patient confidentiality if they believe a patent is an immediate danger to themselves or others.

[Zod]

Gun laws, more gun laws, regulations, more regulations.

Criminal bypasses all and kills legal owner for their guns. Answer? More gun laws

Would Adam have had one if law abiding mom didn't have one?

Nope

[Darth Biscuit]

Would Adam have had one if law abiding mom didn't have one?

Nope

I don't agree with stirs that we're "changing the constitution because of one tragedy" but you have no way of knowing this... if mom hadn't had guns, he could have gotten them from somewhere else.

[Kurb]

Would Adam have had one if law abiding mom didn't have one?

Nope

Would he have done the same or worse either way? Most likely.

[Zod]

Would he have done the same or worse either way? Most likely.

Not at all.

[Kurb]

Not at all.

You can't make a definitive statement on one hypothetical and then disagree with a definitive statement on another hypothetical.