128 replies to this topic

[Khaki Lackey]

Blows my mind that some people once thought he was better than Cam. Not even in the same league. That's like comparing Matt Carroll to Lebron James

Until the Panthers win a playoff game, casual fans and Cam haters will continue to insist that Dalton is better.

[OnlyPantherFaninMaine]

But but but Grits said Dalton was better than Cam! It must be true.

[TheGreatestOfAllTimeCam]

He doesn't suck.

Reminds me of a cross between Phil Simms and Matt Ryan before Ryan got Julio Jones added to the mix.

Dalton has AJ Green and a bunch of guys, and had average protection today. He doesn't suck.

[TheGreatestOfAllTimeCam]

He couldn't hold Cam's jock, but he doesn't suck. And I mean that. Cam is on another planet. He would have sent the Texans home today with a similar supporting cast and that many possessions.

[BigSyke]

i just heard someone compare joe webb to cam newton............................

[CPF4LIFE]

Until the Panthers win a playoff game, casual fans and Cam haters will continue to insist that Dalton is better.

My whole concept is, if you go by that logic then you might as well say Flacco, Sanchez, The Golden Calf of Bristol are better than him too because they took their teams to the playoffs early in careers. Stupid logic.

[TheGreatestOfAllTimeCam]

Until the Panthers win a playoff game, casual fans and Cam haters will continue to insist that Dalton is better.

can't compare apples to apples. No scout or personnel guy in the league would take Dalton over Cam.

But Dalton has had a close to elite defense, AJ Green, and Marvin Lewis is actually a lot better, more experienced tenured head coach than Chico Rivera. All that factors in.

If Newton was on the Bengals (btw, they worked him out quite a bit prior to the draft), they would be a Super Bowl contender.

[Matthias]

Welcome to the playoff couch Bengal fans.

[CPF4LIFE]

Yeah Bengals would definitely be a contender with Cam. Cant put the ball in his hands that many times and not expect him to hurt you.

[I Registered To Post This]

My whole concept is, if you go by that logic then you might as well say Flacco, Sanchez, The Golden Calf of Bristol are better than him too because they took their teams to the playoffs early in careers. Stupid logic.

it comes back to this ridiculous preconceived notion a lot of people have in their heads about "winners" and "losers".

it's an unbelievably stupid, simplistic way to look at a thing as complicated as quarterbacking in the NFL. the guy we just watched, matt schaub, has been houston's starter for six seasons and elevated that team out of complete irrelevancy but this is his first win as a starter in the playoffs. guys like The Golden Calf of Bristol, sanchez, and flacco all got wins before him but only a complete dumbass would dare argue that schaub is inferior to those three.

[Keith Moons Liver]

it comes back to this ridiculous preconceived notion a lot of people have in their heads about "winners" and "losers".

it's an unbelievably stupid, simplistic way to look at a thing as complicated as quarterbacking in the NFL. the guy we just watched, matt schaub, has been houston's starter for six seasons and elevated that team out of complete irrelevancy but this is his first win as a starter in the playoffs. guys like The Golden Calf of Bristol, sanchez, and flacco all got wins before him but only a complete dumbass would dare argue that schaub is inferior to those three.

speaking of simplistic ways of looking at complicated subjects, how about statements like shaub "elevated that team out of complete irrelevancy"?

[Pimpdaddy]

how does he suck? he got the bengals to the playoffs, cam didnt..

[Future Of The Franchise]

he dont suck he just not good in playoffs games........

Romo 2.0

[I Registered To Post This]

speaking of simplistic ways of looking at complicated subjects, how about statements like shaub "elevated that team out of complete irrelevancy"?

who the fug is "shaub"

are you going to argue that going from david carr - matt schaub was not the most important thing that ever happened to that franchise?

[I Registered To Post This]

Romo 2.0

dalton has a long way to go before he's on romo's level