Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

RG3 not built for the NFL

223 posts in this topic

Posted

I dunno about "in 2 years"

But he's not built for the NFL for sure

Ill take Cam ALL DAY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

427692_508850642492517_1593610584_n.jpg

I can't help it, these are freaking funny.

You are still my son's fav poster. B)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I'm still trying to figure out how Aaron Rodgers RG3 got hurt. Did his knee just collapse?

he was already hurt, not 100%

early in the game (late 1st quarter?) he was running towards the sideline and you could see that his knee buckled awkwardly.

they kept him in, though, despite him getting hammered, stumbling around, and looking like he could barely move.

the final straw came when he tried to retrieve a fumble and his knee just completely gave out when he bent over

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

he was already hurt, not 100%

early in the game (late 1st quarter?) he was running towards the sideline and you could see that his knee buckled awkwardly.

they kept him in, though, despite him getting hammered, stumbling around, and looking like he could barely move.

the final straw came when he tried to retrieve a fumble and his knee just completely gave out when he bent over

The question becomes who do you blame more: Griffin for insisting he could keep playing or Shanahan for keeping him in?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

he was already hurt, not 100%

early in the game (late 1st quarter?) he was running towards the sideline and you could see that his knee buckled awkwardly.

they kept him in, though, despite him getting hammered, stumbling around, and looking like he could barely move.

the final straw came when he tried to retrieve a fumble and his knee just completely gave out when he bent over

Not only that, but they kept calling designed runs for him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

The question becomes who do you blame more: Griffin for insisting he could keep playing or Shanahan for keeping him in?

100% on Shanny.

Just about every player is going to want to go back in, regardless. RG3 was pretty obviously injured before the half, that knee has been bad for a while now (bad enough for a doctor to come out to the press before the game and basically say "I didn't allow him back, it's not on me"), they had Cousins on the bench who had come in already this season and delivered a pressure win for them and they still sent him (RG3) back in.

Way to gamble a player's livelihood for a Wildcard win there, Mike.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I absolutely blame Shanahan, that idiot should never have risked his franchise's future by putting RG3 back out there when it was obvious he wasn't even at 60%.

And as for whether RG3 will be able to take hits like that all that often, I don't know. I do know that players attempt to arm tackle Cam far more frequently than they do RG3. Something about 260 lbs of muscle tends to make defenders choose their steps wisely.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

You are still my son's fav poster. B)

I still think your son like my signature. Which is a good thing. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I love you ZOD, but this $hitty thread ruined some of your credibility man. You're suppose to let the huddlers create these stupid topic. Not you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

But he really is NOT built for the NFL. This is first season, and he's had numerous injuries and issues. He'll shatter if he lives by the option and running, and just like we seen in the playoff game, he's not scary enough without the run threat. Maybe he can become a pure pocket passer, who knows. The Redskins didn't even have much confidence in him, hence them drafting Cousins in the 4th round.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

RGIII will be gone in 5 years, tops. Wouldn't be surprised if sooner, due to injury. Having knee issues in your first season when your reputation is a running QB is not good.

He can't throw down field consistently unless the receiver is wide open.

He can't throw as effectively without his run threat.

Those two things are NOT good signs. A QB in this league has to be able to throw the intermediate/long routes while there is some coverage and drop it in an area where a catch is possible. It doesn't have to be a perfect ball, but a catchable ball (even if the receiver has to stretch out for it a bit). I've watched his past few games, and I am just not seeing that. I have seen him skip a ball off the ground on a 15 yard out route where, had he just gotten the ball there, it would have been an impressive, NFL throw.

He's young, so he does get the rookie pass. Let's see him next season. If he comes out and tears it up and shows he can be a consistent passer (or signs that he's heading there), and if he can stay healthy (not likely, IMO), then we can talk like he is going to be around to be compared to Luck and Cam. I'd love to have Cam, Luck, and Bob as the big three QBs in 8-10 years time, but I think that Cam may be the only one (Luck has to get more consistent as well to start those talks).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

It's on the coach, at least as far as we know (e.g., did a doctor say RG3 was good to play? if so, wtf.). RG3 is a young kid that wanted to give his team his all. He has tremendous confidence and doesn't want to let his team down.

It's up to the coach to realize that:

1) He has to protect the health of his players,

2) He has a better chance of winning with a quarterback that can plant and throw, even if it limits the offense in other ways.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites