73 replies to this topic

[Ken]

Cam all the way. Haven't seen anything from these guys to even waver in this opinion.

[k1lljoy_89]

I'm biased.....

1. Cam Newton
2. Russel Wilson
3. Collin Kaepernick
4a. Andrew Luck (Almost 3... Just too many turnovers he's gonna be great though)
4b. RGIII (He needs to start playing smarter he isn't built to run in this league)
5. (Other) Ryan Tannehill etc...
Last a. Sam Bradford
Last b. Andy Dalton

This

[Woodcookedbbq]

Andrew luck is just going to get better and better.

[CRA]

Anyone that says Cam is a homer when you are looking at this season. I will say Colin, simply because he took over for Alex Smith that didn't do anything wrong other than get a concussion. Plus, Colin is going to the Championship game while everyone else is at home watching.

Sanchez went to a championship game as a rookie and sophomore....

I don't think it is homeristic to say Cam....Wilson looked better this year but physically Newton still has a tremendous ceiling. So Cam could be a reasonable choice if you are looking at who to build around.

Wilson is ahead of Cam currently in terms of understanding the Cam and more diverse throws.....but 4 years of college vs 1 of legit college probably factors in

[ThunderKatt]

Colin is my choice at the point. When you go to lenders, they look at potential but they want more collateral than if you have a history of doing and right now Colin is doing.

[carolina-chuck]

Russell Wilson
Colin Kaepernick
Cam Newton
RGIII
Andrew Luck
Andy Dalton
Poor Bradford

[TheGreatestOfAllTimeCam]

Man.... Too tough.

Wilson with a small edge on Cam.... Then Luck

[panthers04100]

Cam, Kaepernick, Wilson, and RG3(if he can stay healthy) are gonna have some great playoff battles these next 10 years.

[Navy_football]

Russell Wilson
Colin Kaepernick
Cam Newton
RGIII
Andrew Luck
Andy Dalton
Poor Bradford

I agree with this, except Bradford is better than Luck and Dalton.

[ThunderKatt]

Sanchez went to a championship game as a rookie and sophomore....

I don't think it is homeristic to say Cam....Wilson looked better this year but physically Newton still has a tremendous ceiling. So Cam could be a reasonable choice if you are looking at who to build around.

Wilson is ahead of Cam currently in terms of understanding the Cam and more diverse throws.....but 4 years of college vs 1 of legit college probably factors in

Yea, but Sanchez wasn't the reason why the went to the championship, their defense was the only reason why they made it. The defense cleaned up Sanchezs mess all season.

[Brooklyn Bully]

It's really a tie between Cam and Wilson. But we had to vote for one. Luck will break Cam's "two year" record next season, but we'll see how he handles his slump. RGIII will slump and probably get injured. Kap will regress and I don't see him becoming much of anything in the league. Wilson, however, won't slump, IMO. He'll shine once again next season.

[theyhateme45]

If Bradford is being named, I think tannahil should have gotten a spot on the list. I think we can all agree on gabbert and ponder being the worst..

Also that entire 2010 qb draft class might be the worst ever in the nfl!

[mountainpantherfan2]

I voted for Cam because I'm a homer but the truth is there has been a nice influx of talented QBs the last two drafts.

[rscott94]

If Bradford is being named, I think tannahil should have gotten a spot on the list. I think we can all agree on gabbert and ponder being the worst..

Also that entire 2010 qb draft class might be the worst ever in the nfl!

Agreed on Tannehill... As for the worst QB if Dalton didn't have AJ Green he'd be Jimmy Clausen (just my opinion)

[Jackofalltrades]

Kaepernick.