Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

DaCityKats

DCK Mock Draft

95 posts in this topic

I actually don't mind this mock in all honesty but I think we should try to get a safety in the 5th instead. Otherwise I wouldn't hate it

i thought about Josh Evans from Florida in the 5th but felt like CB was a bigger need and value there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't mind it, but like others I'm not sold on taking a WR in the first when so little seems to separate Allen from the other top 5 or so WRs. Then in the 2nd instead of taking a DT you got us taking some OG I hadn't even heard of. I'm not saying its a bad pick because I haven't heard of him, I'm just saying IF we're ignoring DT I'd feel better about getting Barrett Jones or Larry Warford. As your mock plays out I'd feel pretty much the same way I felt when we took Silatolu. Don't know much about him, I'd wait til I knew more, but there were other guys I'd prefer we had taken. If Geathers is our attempt at addressing the dire need at DT I'd just hope and pray he plays a lot better in the NFL than what I saw of him in college.

To clarify, I wouldn't mind the Allen pick. But I'd be just as happy with Hunter, Patterson, Hopkins or Rogers. I'd also be just as happy with any of those guys or Patton or Woods in the 2nd.

huge difference with Amini who played D2 football and Frederick who played at Wisconsin.everybody knows that UW produces OL and this guy has been apart of the program for 3+ years. has started at 2 different postions,tough, smart and has good size. plus if something does happened to Kalil you got a nice back up center to fill his spot. i would like any WR in the 2nd with OL or DT in the first but what seperates Allen from Hunter, Patterson, and Rogers is being consistent and no off field issues. Nuk is a baller and i would love to have him too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Logan is more of an UT right? We need a run stuffer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we go offense in the 1st, I think we would be better served getting a lineman. That geathers kid is HUGE though and would love to see him eating up the middle.

would you rather have the 4th or 5th rated OL or the 1st rated WR?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Logan is more of an UT right? We need a run stuffer.

Edit: yea just looked him up. Logan's 290. He might be a solid player, but at least Geathers is of the mold we need.

2nd edit: dumbass iPad posting double posted

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Who's better? Bennie Logan or Geathers.

depends on what position as Logan is more suited to play the 3 tech while Geathers is more of a NT/1 tech.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Logan is more of an UT right? We need a run stuffer.

Edit: yea just looked him up. Logan's 290. He might be a solid player, but at least Geathers is of the mold we need.

yes he is a 3 tech.i think he is a decent prospect as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

huge difference with Amini who played D2 football and Frederick who played at Wisconsin.everybody knows that UW produces OL and this guy has been apart of the program for 3+ years. has started at 2 different postions,tough, smart and has good size. plus if something does happened to Kalil you got a nice back up center to fill his spot. i would like any WR in the 2nd with OL or DT in the first but what seperates Allen from Hunter, Patterson, and Rogers is being consistent and no off field issues. Nuk is a baller and i would love to have him too.

I didn't mean to imply they're similar players, just comparing how they're relative unknowns without much hype or talk of going that high. At least not yet...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't mean to imply they're similar players, just comparing how they're relative unknowns without much hype or talk of going that high. At least not yet...

unknown to some, but from everything i read is he just as good if not better prospect as Peter Konz was coming out last year. they both started at OG before switching to C and leaving for the NFL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites