Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Gil Brandt ranks Cam 7th best QB under 30

98 posts in this topic

Posted

Not to mad about cam's placement besides the fact that only reason he's faulting him is because of his "sideline crap" but that list is poo.

No, he said he would have placed him higher had he played in the first half of the season at the same level as he did in the second half. Pretty simple and hard to argue I would think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

marcjames

I asked Bill Polian where he would draft Cam Newton Today with RGIII, Luck, Wilson, & Kaepernick, he said: "At the Bottom." #Panthers

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

fug Marc James and Bill Polian.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

i've said it before...bill polian and his opinion is severely overrated around here.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Marc James is always trying to get other people to say the things he wont say out loud. He doesnt care much for Cam either but wont say it out loud since he works for a Carolina radio station. He is a Andrew Luck jock sniffer. He already knew Polian didnt like Cam and was gonna say that. fug him, he does this poo all the time.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Polian is so smart he has job offers on the table just doesn't want to take them

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

My response to the pretentious douche.

@marcjames I asked Panthers fans where would they rank Marc James as a talk show host, they said "At the bottom."
2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

My response to the pretentious douche.

nice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Whether by selective camera work by the media or not, I still stand by the "more involvement" thing. No, I wasn't able to make it to a game this year and I'm going by just what I see through the TV.

I do see Cam shedding the pouting behavior after something adverse, which is wonderful. But I have never seen him looking at pictures, film, talking with coaches, etc on the sidelines.

That is what I want to see from my young quarterback. Maybe I need to get to a game in 2013 to see that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I guess Gil didn't get the memo on the Early Season Chud-Offense Fiasco, huh? LOL

I respect him on many things NFL, and even Cam. However, he doesn't appear to have followed the team and is just winging it for this piece (that's why he left it open, regarding Cam's "unlimited potential", as if Kaepernick and Luck aren't any more raw than Cam right now), with his comments. LOL. Cam has always been active on the sidelines, especially lately, regardless of what and when the media said it. That was a manufactured issue. I'm surprised so many Panther fans--even fall for that.

Now if he's limiting Cam from what he didn't do during the second half of the 2012 season (and totally ignoring what he did during his first season), then how the hell does he have Kaepernick (a guy that's only started 9 games), and even Luck--a rookie ranked higher!? Such a small sample size. I'm sure this list is very fluid and subject to change, but still. Come on Gil.

Makes no sense. But it's all good. I guess, the better way to look at it is: Cam would have been higher on the list, if he didn't have such a poor start (thanks Chud), and if the media started showing him talking to his teammates and coaches more, which he does. SMH/LOL. To each is own.

I am surprised because isn't Cam and Gil tight? Gil like moon has been in his corner the last 2 years. I actually have thought that Gil and Moon are the guys Cam uses as his voice in the media to say he things he can't say (like most big time players have a person in the that does the dirty work for them).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I am surprised because isn't Cam and Gil tight? Gil like moon has been in his corner the last 2 years. I actually have thought that Gil and Moon are the guys Cam uses as his voice in the media to say he things he can't say (like most big time players have a person in the that does the dirty work for them).

i think he's just been expecting more. one of the elements that brandt raved about was his leadership and influence on the guys on the sidelines and it just hasn't been there like it was at auburn and like was expected. he's needed to be influenced rather than be an influence. he's having growing pains and he isn't at the level he should be and is capable of being yet.

numbers aside, he's been a little disappointing up until the last few games of the season. if he can start back at that level and maintain it, he'll be rising up those lists.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I am surprised because isn't Cam and Gil tight? Gil like moon has been in his corner the last 2 years. I actually have thought that Gil and Moon are the guys Cam uses as his voice in the media to say he things he can't say (like most big time players have a person in the that does the dirty work for them).

All true. But I guess we gotta remember 1), this is a current list, that's subject to change (and Brandt, said as much regarding Cam's first half/having him higher). 2) I guess he's trying to be fair (because of what you mentioned) and show perspective. This way, no one can call him a homer. I get it.

It's all good. I'm sure like Moon (when he was recently asked on WFNZ), he'd take Cam for the future (or argue he's just as good as Luck and Wilson).

The Kaepernick ranking, is the one outlyer to me. I mean, you hate to keep saying it: But career bust, Alex Smith put up a top 5 QB rating, and went to the Conference finals last year, with the same team, before his 2 yr back up started the last 9 games, bringing them into the Super Bowl.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites