48 replies to this topic

[chknwing]

dumbest thread of the year nominee?

[Goondal]

Cam

[CatMan72]

It's a QB league, Cam.

[Doc Holiday]

Cam and it isn't even close, we have Beason still on the team you know, 3 time probowler and 2 time all pro MLB apparently not many remember he is indeed on the team still and may be the better MLB.

I still can't figure out the complete ignoring of Beason being on the team with him being already a great MLB and proven leader on the team. Only way I can explain it is just a "new shinny" mentality. Kinda sad when you think about it.

[Gucci Mane]

Kuechly at MLB is our best option with Beason on the outside, unless we can move to a 3-4

[Growl]

so which thread is worse.

This one, or fieryprophets Harbaugh tirade

[Growl]

Irv's isn't a viable nomination.

[carolina-chuck]

I'm bout to give Cam a new $100mil contract and Kuechly a $70mil contract

[teeray]

I always go QB first. A great QB can make up for a lot more deficiencies team wide than an ILB.

[Growl]

Cams contract is going to be the biggest in league history. 100 million is dreaming. You're overpaying for Kuechly. Assume he'll pull in about 50 mill.

[CarolinaPride5]

Obviously Cam no questions asked.

[Mage]

I always question individual position judgment questions in the context of a team sport, especially at the pro level.

Say you have a great QB? Cool. Stick him with mediocre receivers, a lousy offensive line and crummy backs and congrats, you have Archie Manning.

I don't see this discussion as much different than the ones where people ask if you'd rather have great covers or dominant pass rushers. You need both.

If it's discussion for the heck of it, fine, but it's not very realistic.

Yes, you need both. My point is however nobody is saying otherwise.

It is, "who is more important (basically who is more vital to our success) - Cam Newton or Luke Kuechly?" It isn't about if defense is needed or not. We know defense is important. But QB >> MLB by a good amount. Like someone said earlier, you are more likely to find playoff teams with average MLBs than you will average QBs. And the playoff teams with average QBs don't often last long.

So it is a simple question. Would you rather have Cam or Kuechly?

[nctarheel0619]

Ask the Saints if defense matters (and they had one of the league's best QBs)



Team building is my framework for the question.

Mind you, there's no way I'd minimize the importance of the QB spot, but I don't like an unbalanced approach to roster building. And like I said, I build from the lines first.

Still can't believe the Saints* had more than 5 wins with the worst defense ever!

[Peppers90 NC]

QB duh