Posted 14 February 2013 - 02:03 AM
According to Panthers.com DWill averaged 4.3 ypc with 5TDs, while Stew did 3.6 with 1TD. Winner DWill. Stew averaged 9.2 yards per catch with 1 TD, while DWill had 14.3 with 2TDs. Winner DWill. A down year for both, but DWill still was close to avg.
Oh and DWill's longest run of 65 yards is triple Stew's 21. Again, winner DWill.
Too bad he costs so much.
Stew ain't bad. He just isn't a homerun hitter like DWill.
Also, there was a linked article on here recently that said DWill had more yards after contact that Stew. So that myth is also busted.
Personally, I would rather have DWill on this team. If that works out, great. If it doesn't, we still have, cough cough, Stew and Tolbert. Still reliable backs. Just not the threat DWill is. And I believe you need all the threats you can get in todays NFL.