I will repeat it....in the 14 games against teams that weren't the worst defensive unit in NFL history.....his ypc was 3.3.
The NO games greatly masked how unimpressive he was this year. Those 2 games also caused his ypc to jump a full yard....and most of his TDs as well.
And to answer your question....if I am going to pay money....give me the young RB who fits what the coach ideally wants. That ain't Williams.
Neither of our RBs ran well this year. So either they both need to go, or we need to fix what was wrong. We let Chud go, and will probably address the O-line. Both of those should help our RBs excel again next year. If so, and we can work out something with DWill to alow us to keep him. I will take DWill.
Stew is a fine back, but again, he is no homerun threat. You need homerun threats to compete.
And if you know what the coach ideally wants, you are in rarified air. Because we are in the dark as to what they want at this point. It could be either or both types. Who knows.
I want DWill, you want Stew. Only time will tell who is going to be happiest.