Just realized that R.J. Umberger can play both Center and Wing. I think his versatility gets him over Stafford. Both had same points last season, which was a low 18, but both were really good before last season. However, Umberger's stats look most impressive.
Also, I looked at the 2010 team on wiki and they had 3 goalies so I am going to add Quick and remove Legwand. I think Umberger's versatility is important even though Legwand has better stats as a center than Umberger recently.