62 replies to this topic

[Mr. Scot]

I have a feeling certain aspects of this list will be...unpopular

Greatest Players in Panthers History

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Too much youth and inexperience. We need more of a veteran presence.

[jtm]

I think that's a pretty good list--very subjective of course.

[OneBadCat]

I think the list is spot on the for the most part but Steve Smith is #1.

I see Peppers at #4 or 5 and I don't think Rucker should be on this list at all.

Cam's not an all time Panther great yet imo. I think Minter or Gamble would deserve mention over him.

[carolina-chuck]

GREAT LIST!

Only thing missing is LaFail. Jk
But missing Minter.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Oh, are you guys getting an actual list because I got sent to a gallery of panthers cheerleaders. Not complaining though. Actually prefer it.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Oh, I found it. Still prefer the cheerleaders, but I would put Gross ahead of Jenkins and Smitty ahead of everybody. Other than that it's kinda fudgable. Not a ton of separation.

[AggieLean.]

Pretty good list. You could flip flop Peppers and Smith, but pretty good list.

[Mr. Scot]

For the lazy

10. Wesley Walls

9. Cam Newton

8. Jon Beason

7. Jake Delhomme

6. Jordan Gross

5. Kris Jenkins

4. Mike Rucker

3. Muhsin Muhammad

2. Steve Smith

1. Julius Peppers


How do you not have Sam Mills on this list? And no Mike Minter?

[OneBadCat]

Pretty sure Peppers said he wants to retire a Bear. For that I am an eternal hater. Therefore he can't be #1.

[Doyle]

Why beason and no Morgan?

[Sapper]

Sam Mills is one of my favorite Panthers of all time. But he only played here for 3 years - his presence was much more about inspiration since he was in the twilight of his career at the beginning of the franchise.

Minter should definitely be on there.

[JccOldTime23]

I don't like Peppers at #1. He belongs on the list for sure but his lack of heart & desire puts him out of the top 5 for me. Otherwise good list.

[SCMunnerlyn1]

Take out Cam for Minter IMO idc about the order. Cam hasn't been here long enough for me.

[hepcat]

Peppers over Smith???? NO.