62 replies to this topic

[iamhubby1]

What? No Kasay?

Minter, Buckner, and Morgan. What about Lathom?

Is it bad I can't think of any offesnesive players? Wharton was valuable for as long as some of the others.

This is hard. Lists like this are stupid.

Every name on that list is a homegrown product. Except Walls, and he is 10th. So, if that is a criteria? Not going to be able to improve on that list by much, if any.

[SuperMan]

Smitty is the greatest panther so far...


Peppers has been replaced by two double digit sack guys.

[OneBadCat]

Smitty is the greatest panther so far...


Peppers has been replaced by two double digit sack guys.

Damn straight. I'll take Greg Hardy and Charles Johnson over Peppers anyday.

[cbully]

kj is the only suspect on the list imo.

[bigdog10]

Yep.

I would swap Minter for Jenkins and readjust the alignment some.

[Growl]

That's an awful list

[jtnc]

Peppers as the best Panther.

[CRA]

Rucker at 4 is much worse than Peppers at 1.

Depends what best Panther means. Overall, Pep was the biggest freak for the longest period.

[jtnc]

Rucker at 4 is much worse than Peppers at 1.

Depends what best Panther means. Overall, Pep was the biggest freak for the longest period.

We already know Peppers definitely had an effort issue, Peppers WISH he had the heart Steve has.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Sam Mills is one of my favorite Panthers of all time. But he only played here for 3 years - his presence was much more about inspiration since he was in the twilight of his career at the beginning of the franchise.

Minter should definitely be on there.

Cam has only played here two years. And if you think Mills was just here as an inspiration, you need to go back and look at the stats from those first two years.

[jtnc]

Cam has only played here two years. And if you think Mills was just here as an inspiration, you need to go back and look at the stats from those first two years.

Cam has only played here two years, and yet he's probably the most known Panther.

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Cam has only played here two years, and yet he's probably the most known Panther.

Popular does not equal best.

Then The Golden Calf of Bristol would be the best Bronco and Jet ever.

[Gabeking]

I'm about to throw up at this, Mills has a statue at this stadium and meant more to the team than people think, he needs to at least be at 10 if not higher.. best players doesnt always have to mean the most talented either i mean peppers at 1 is an insult, the CJ and hardy duo provided an overall better pass rushing game than he did and smith not at 1 is a disgrace as well... And if you want to go by talent alone then why isnt morgan on this list?? should be top 3 the way this bozo made it.. Just my two cents

[jtnc]

Popular does not equal best.

Then The Golden Calf of Bristol would be the best Bronco and Jet ever.

Are you honestly comparing Cam to The Golden Calf of Bristol? There is no correlation, Cam has accounted for 63 touchdowns in only TWO seasons. Get out of here, with this tomfoolery. That's already more than Steve Smith's career receiving touchdowns.

[Daddy Uncle]

Cam Newton, Luke Kuechly, and Steve Smith will be the #1, 2, and on the list for a long time.