62 replies to this topic

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Are you honestly comparing Cam to The Golden Calf of Bristol? There is no correlation, Cam has accounted for 63 touchdowns in only TWO seasons. Get out of here, with this tomfoolery.

If you want to use the "statistic" of popularity like it matters, then yeah they are on the same level. Which shows how silly popularity is as an argument.

[Daddy Uncle]

I can't beleive Tyrone Poole didn't make that list

[SuperMan]

Are you honestly comparing Cam to The Golden Calf of Bristol? There is no correlation, Cam has accounted for 63 touchdowns in only TWO seasons. Get out of here, with this tomfoolery. That's already more than Steve Smith's career receiving touchdowns.

Your reading comprehension is off buddy....

[Ivan The Awesome]

Peppers is so freaking overrated.

[BigBoss]

No, he's not. It's so easy to hate on him because he left us and didn't tap into the potential he was hyped to have, but he really was just incredible for the Panthers, and I'm happy for the time we had him.

No John Kasey is an injustice though. Why does it seem like only the fans saw him as a amazing Panther?

[csx]

Cam has only played here two years, and yet he's probably the most known Panther.

He is the current best known Panther and the best known Panther to the new fans but to those of us who have been following since before day 1 there is quite a bit more competition in the best known of all time category.

The list is close enough....and for God's sake it's just a meaningless list.

[jtnc]

He is the current best known Panther and the best known Panther to the new fans but to those of us who have been following since before day 1 there is quite a bit more competition in the best known of all time category.

The list is close enough....and for God's sake it's just a meaningless list.

I agree. He should probably be ranked 10th, and Sam Mills SHOULD be on the list

[Sapper]

Cam has only played here two years. And if you think Mills was just here as an inspiration, you need to go back and look at the stats from those first two years.

I don't need to look at stats, I was at every home game for his 3 years at Carolina - so I got to see his presence first hand.

[Ivan The Awesome]

Eh, never mind the link isn't working.

[bleys]

Julius Peppers over Steve Smith? lmao

[scarface]

Peppers is so freaking overrated.

he had 309 tackles, 81 sacks, 30 fumbles forced and 6 INT as a Panther.




....but Steve Smith should definitely be #1.

[KendrickPanther]

Without really checking it looks like that list was done by someone that's not a Panthers fan.I would take Rucker off. Move Wesley Walls up, move Jon Beason down. Move Jordan Gross down. Add Deangelo Williams and think about dropping someone for Kevin Greene.

[Promethean Forerunner]

Judas Peppers should not be on this list. I'll consider him at Top 25 but not Top 10. I despise him too much for me to consider him apart of Panthers' history.

[CRA]

Julius Peppers over Steve Smith? lmao

Peppers gets hate but his production is there...

The angry man attitude vs. the laid back approach comes into play in how he is viewed here....and Peppers dumping us (which was understandable).

Peppers not punching out 3 teammates and bringing drama easily could put him ahead slightly from the non Panther fans viewpoint

[Growl]

Panthers fans are seeing how much they overvalued Peppers while he was here now that he's on another team and still doesn't get elite tier recognition.

He's a talented player but his inconsistency, lack of explosiveness, and one dimensional ability as a pass rusher kept him from being elite.