Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Panthro

Wealth Inequality in America

Recommended Posts

Kurb    4,984

some people just make better mechanics than they do neurosurgeons

I agree 100% and there is absolutely nothing wrong with being either.

My thing is I don't want that to be decided by birth.

All this said, I still would wager that America is one of the most upwardly mobile countries in the world.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Darth Biscuit    12,503

I agree with Kurb.

Life is inherently unfair... moreso for some than others.

I think a BIG, HUGE part of the solution in America is our education system. It sucks. For a country of our vast wealth our education system is beyond pathetic.

some people just make better mechanics than they do neurosurgeons

This is true... and back to education, we do a crap job of identifying kids abilities and teaching them.

  • Pie 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Panthro    9,937

some people just make better mechanics than they do neurosurgeons

I agree.

They pry make only 10x more too. Not that crazy...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Happy Panther    3,966

This is true... and back to education, we do a crap job of identifying kids abilities and teaching them.

I may have posted this here but of of the biggest education turnoffs for students is calculus. It's high on the list of reasons for dropout. Future mechanics don't need calculus so don't make it a required subject. Mechanics can make tons of money.

With schools measured on test scores these days it is hard to do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Darth Biscuit    12,503

I may have posted this here but of of the biggest education turnoffs for students is calculus. It's high on the list of reasons for dropout. Future mechanics don't need calculus so don't make it a required subject. Mechanics can make tons of money.

With schools measured on test scores these days it is hard to do.

My son took the ACT in school yesterday... the entire eleventh grade had to take it. Are all of those kids going to college? No.

I can see how it turns kids off from school.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Panthro    9,937

My son took the ACT in school yesterday... the entire eleventh grade had to take it. Are all of those kids going to college? No.

I can see how it turns kids off from school.

Yep. I wish community colleges focused on trades and certs more than AA's.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Panthro    9,937

I don't get where you are forming this opinion from ?

Panthro is likely one of the "least concerned with what other people have" people I know.

I think he feels there is a significant Lack of Ladders to the Top. Especially for those born on the wrong side of the track.

While I feel this is partially true, what PSC is saying is also true.

Yes you were born in the trailer park.

Yes it's going to be harder for you than the kid whose parents make 1 Mill a year plus.

But that doesn't mean you can't be successful.

I think everyone can agree with that ?

If we could open more doorways to success for those who don't have it AND turn the corner on the defeatist culture that is prevalent (assumed) in lower income class brackets we could turn a corner not only as a country but as a generation.

Granted potentialdemotivator.jpg

is also true.

But that shouldn't be predetermined by where you were born or what race/sex you are.

untitledghgfhhghjgh.jpeg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jase    12,328

I'm at least a 2-pat bro hugger. I challenge the validity of that graphic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teeray    16,195

I wish that even at the public high school level there was more opportunity for vocational studies.

They need to bring back auto repair classes, woodworking, etc, so people that may not be interested in pursuing college, or that aren't as gifted in math and science can learn about something that is helpful for them finding a career opportunity and that gives them perhaps a boost in self confidence.

That would be a way of perhaps giving kids who don't excel in math and science, or don't have the grade to get accepted at a university or college, or doesn't have the money to go to higher learning institutions, or don't know certain programs even exist in technical schools; it may give those kids some direction rather than flunking them out of school and sending them out on their own to figure it out.

Instead of heading back to their lives feeling like a failure and possibly in poverty stricken areas, they might find they like or have a talent in areas other than math and science that they can pursue and give them hope that there is still a way out of poverty or a way to make it in the world even if it means they may not going to get rich doing it.

  • Pie 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pstall    5,759

Some see the problem and think govt of their elected officials will solve it.

At times I think the US is too big and diverse for its own good. Everybody doesn't get a trophy and not everybody even wants one.

Been saying for years need more apprenticeships set up.

  • Pie 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Davidson Deac II    4,210

and some people never get a shot... because life (as we've constructed it) is unfair. this situation wasn't created in a vacuum, we aren't operating in the natural order... if we were, those with excess would've been strung up by the have-nots long ago, the whole point of civilization is act as a group to benefit the group.

I wouldn't say some people never get a shot, although its a certainity that some people have a far more difficult path than others. But it is still possible to overcome circumstances and be successful. I grew up in difficult circumstances, and I knew some that had it worse than I did. Made the best of it, and so far I am doing ok. Some of those I grew up with are doing ok, some not so much.

You have to take the few opportunities that are available, and make the best of them. But I am for giving the underpriveldged as many opportunities as we can, assuming we can afford it.

IMO, the primary issue in the country is not wealth inequality, but the breakdown of the family. To many children grow up in broken or abusive homes. But thats for another thread.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teeray    16,195

Some see the problem and think govt of their elected officials will solve it.

At times I think the US is too big and diverse for its own good. Everybody doesn't get a trophy and not everybody even wants one.

Been saying for years need more apprenticeships set up.

Did we just agree on something!! 551.gif

Of course I want these programs set up through public school system, which would take considerable taxpayer money and our government fixing a problem, so we probably don't see 100% eye to eye.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×