Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Woodcookedbbq

Sen. Rand Paul is Giving a Genuine Filibuster

86 posts in this topic

“The condition that an operational leader presents an ‘imminent’ threat of violent attack against the United States does not require the United States to have clear evidence that a specific attack on US persons and interests will take place in the immediate future.”

this is the problem as far as i see it. during rand's thing, durbin basically asked what you're asking (specifically saying that flight 93 would have been shot down had it not crashed, and that that would have been the correct thing to do) and that wasn't even really contested. it's the twisting of the word "imminent" that has created the weird union between aclu types and assholes like rand paul

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not forgetting the fact that Rand Paul is a nutjob that feels private businesses should be able to be racist or not accommodate people with disabilities, this is an interesting discussion to have, regardless.

So what if, like in the scenario Holden gave and Paul blew up for political gain, we were faced with a hijacked place full of people speeding towards NY, Houston, Chicago, etc and we had a drone in the air nearby? I think most would agree that, horrible as it would be, you take down the plane.

The question is how do you allow for that, but still make it difficult to legally justify a more mundane killing?

It's good that the far right is starting to come around to the questions a lot of us had years ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The pres should not have powers of judge jury and executioner. Brennan does not appear to believe this is so. thats what the fillibuster is about. hypotheticals do nothing for this arguement.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The NSA and the DHS are not part of the military.

It would be political suicide to use a drone for anything like this unless you were sure beyond a reasonable doubt that the person being monitored was on their way to perform an attack and there was a chance conventional law enforcement would not be able to stop them. Again, chances are remote but there is a chance, so I think this was just CYA.

The NSA is part of the military. It falls under the DOD and its leader is usually a general or an admiral. Currently, its General Keith Alexander.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

can anyone in here think of a situation conceivable in which knocking out an individual with a drone would be beneficial to the greater good of a vast number of people?

If South Carolina tries the succession thing again. :) Last time, they used warships, muskets and cannon against them, this time it will be tanks and drones (to go after the leaders). A highly unlikely circumstance of course, but then thats what is meant by extreme circumstances.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

can anyone in here think of a situation conceivable in which knocking out an individual with a drone would be beneficial to the greater good of a vast number of people?

If we could nuke DC, that would be a great start in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How is anyone with a blanket authority to kill US citizens w/o some form of due process?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Questions were posed about non combatants on American soil and no assurances given. Only, "we don't intend to". Well, what about 20 years from now? Who will be operating with this set of open rules then?

Very short sighted to put in something without looking to the future

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Questions were posed about non combatants on American soil and no assurances given. Only, "we don't intend to". Well, what about 20 years from now? Who will be operating with this set of open rules then?

Very short sighted to put in something without looking to the future

that's my problem with it, you open the door to a lot of hazy interpretation down the road. a dangerous precedent to set unless you're very specific right off the bat as far as how use of them is restricted/regulated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • yeah those kids are really going to do a number on him!!!!   goodoleboy the goodoleracist
    • Cleveland Browns: Myles Garrett, DE San Francisco 49ers: Mitch Trubisky, QB Chicago Bears: Jamal Adams, S Jacksonville Jaguars: Leonard Fournette, RB Tennessee Titans: Marshon Lattimore, CB New York Jets: Patrick Mahomes, QB LA Chargers: Malik Hooker, S Carolina Panthers: Derek Barnett, DE Cincinnati Bengals: Garrett Bolles, OT Buffalo Bills: Deshaun Watson, QB New Orleans Saints Jonathan Allen DE Cleveland Browns: DeShone Kizer QB Arizona Cardinals: OJ Howard, TE Philadelphia Eagles: Christian McCaffrey, RB Indianapolis Colts: Reuben Foster, LB Baltimore Ravens: Solomon Thomas, DE Washington Redskins: Dalvin Cook, RB Tennessee Titans: Mike Williams, WR Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Taco Charlton, DE Denver Broncos: Ryan Ramczyk, OT Detroit Lions: Corey Davis, WR Miami Dolphins: Haason Reddick, OLB New York Giants: Marlon Humphrey, CB Oakland Raiders: Quincy Wilson, CB Houston Texans: Takkarist McKinley, OLB  Seattle Seahawks: Forrest Lamp. LT Kansas City Chiefs: Tim Williams, DE Dallas Cowboys: Jabril Peppers, S/LB Green Bay Packers: Malik McDowell, DE Pittsburgh Steelers: Evan Engram, TE  Atlanta Falcons       Budda Baker, FS New Orleans Saints  Gareon Conley, CB Cleveland Browns: Cam Robinson, OT San Francisco 49ers: Obi Melifonwu, S Jacksonville Jaguars: Charles Harris, DE Chicago Bears: David Njoku, TE LA Rams: John Ross, WR LA Chargers: Cooper Krupp, WR New York Jets: Antonio Garcia, OT Carolina Panthers: Zay Jones, WR Cincinnati Bengals:Teez Tabor, CB  New Orleans Saints: Juju Smith, WR  Philadelphia Eagles: TJ Watt, OLB Buffalo Bills: Curtis Samuel, WR Arizona Cardinals: Zach Cunningham, LB Indianapolis Colts: Desmond King, CB/FS Baltimore Ravens: Pat Elflein, C Minnesota Vikings: Dan Feeney, G Washington Redskins: Ryan Anderson, ILB Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Ethan Pocic, C Denver Broncos: Cleveland Browns: Detroit Lions: Miami Dolphins: New York Giants: Oakland Raiders: Houston Texans: Seattle Seahawks: Kansas City Chiefs: Dallas Cowboys: Green Bay Packers: Pittsburgh Steelers: Atlanta Falcons: Carolina Panthers: @LinvilleGorge you are on the clock with the Denver Broncos