Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Further evidence that WR trumps O-Line as a need (PFF edition).

151 posts in this topic

Posted

look at who this team has worked out.lot of top ranked WRs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Considering the top guys on this list are all mobile QBs (rg3, wilson, vick, luck) do you think the numbers are inflated for them because of their ability (or in Cams case, NEED to) avoid defenders in the pocket before throwing, taking off or taking a sack?

Caz if you think of a play like the 3rd and 11 vs ATL (game 2), he was probably in the pocket with that DT on his back for a good 4 seconds before breaking the LOS. Cam does this sort of thing pretty often so I wouldn't be surprised if it inflated his numbers a good bit.

I'd like to see a list showing how long until a defender forces the QB to make a decision, such as having to avoid a sack, taking a sack, having to check down from pressure, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Very interesting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Your doing exactly what you accused me of doing. Hypocrite.

No poo, McGoo. That's why I said

Hey, skewing words and making your own opinions IS more fun. Neato!!!

Sarcasm is not a river in Egypt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

couldn't read all of that. my brain itches

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

The stat that is missing is time until under pressure. Sometimes a QB will hold onto a ball longer to extend the play because they came under pressure early and couldn't safely get the ball off. I'm not sure if that would necessarily be the case but it's the most relevant stat for this sort of argument.

Sure the 2.5 secs until sack argument could be made, but Cam is mobile enough to mitigate that early rush and buy some time before he gets taken down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

The OL does need to be improved...providing better protection and a more potent running game (another great friend to a young QB,

However, we also need a dynamic playmaker in the passing game....but I could see that either bring a speedy WR or even a top TE target (2nd round for TE mind you).

Combination if OL and WR in the first two rounds is my hope...in which order depends on who us there at 14 and how our staff feels about the top guys.

Bottom line is that we can't go wrong with either.

I know we do need an infusion at DT, but their bust rate and length of time to really make an impact makes me nervous. Although I would not be upset if we took a top DT at 14 either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

The OL does need to be improved...providing better protection and a more potent running game (another great friend to a young QB,

However, we also need a dynamic playmaker in the passing game....but I could see that either bring a speedy WR or even a top TE target (2nd round for TE mind you).

Combination if OL and WR in the first two rounds is my hope...in which order depends on who us there at 14 and how our staff feels about the top guys.

Bottom line is that we can't go wrong with either.

I know we do need an infusion at DT, but their bust rate and length of time to really make an impact makes me nervous. Although I would not be upset if we took a top DT at 14 either.

If the Panthers bring in Roy Miller or Casey Hampton or some other vet DT(NT), I can dig going WR/OL with the first two picks. Then focus on the DL in later rounds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

If the Panthers bring in Roy Miller or Casey Hampton or some other vet DT(NT), I can dig going WR/OL with the first two picks. Then focus on the DL in later rounds.

Roy Miller is a Jaguar, I believe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

If the Panthers bring in Roy Miller or Casey Hampton or some other vet DT(NT), I can dig going WR/OL with the first two picks. Then focus on the DL in later rounds.

you already have a guy who can compete at the same level as those 2 in Frank Kearse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

i love people freaking out over adding a WR early because of some misguided perception that those wanting to do that feel ok ignoring OL and DT or other positions when that just isn't the case at all.

most understand that it's a clusterf*ck of sorts. we HAVE to have better blocking AND we HAVE to have better targets for cam. we need more play makers and touchdown scorers. we can not afford to sit back on the crop of WRs we have and expect success. same with blocking...except it's easier and quicker to fix the OL and DT in FA than WR. we have more solid choices available at DT and OL than we do for WR.

would i hate to pass up on great OL talent in this draft? yep...but not at the expense of getting the playmaker that would help the most if gettleman thinks it would help the team more to draft one and address OL in FA. wanting to take advantage of quality players at a certain position just because they are there is just as bad and narrow minded as picking a position out of need.

you have to look at the big picture and see where you can get talent to fill your holes and needs and you also have to look at the time to develop players. you've got to pick not just the best talent in the draft, but early you have to get the guy you think can be the quickest contributor. more than likely, that's not going to be OL. a weak link on the OL (which you could pretty much count on any OL not taken in the first few picks) can do more damage to an offense than a struggling WR. that's why you address immediate OL needs in FA rather than the draft. once you have all the pieces in place for a solid OL, then you start drafting for an elite one....unless you are planning on sucking for a few years, which the panthers can't afford to do.

just my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

What if a pro ready Left tackle fell to 14? Which would you choose then?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites