What is your logic behind that? no one else could of made plays against the Saints?
Also you could argue Carolina being forced to play Tolbert more could of helped us considering the OL we had....
That's a valid point. But he made key, big plays in a few games that put the game out of reach.
All I'm saying is no other RB was making those big runs. Could someone else have? Sure. Could a different running approach with Tolbert have worked? Sure. But with the limited carries RBs were getting from Chud, big plays were needed to make the running game a factor.