oh god, one of these guys.... im guessing he makes PS at best, what is your "wager"?
Barner will make the 53 over Poole and Smith. He brings an element they don't. He's got better hands. More likely a better return option than either. Maybe more than anyone outside of Ginn, whos on a 1 year deal. He provides a more reliable weapon out of the option. And capable of playing the slot more effectively than any RB on the team. So tell us why he won't make the 53?
BTW, put him on the PS and he's as good as gone.