We will agree to disagree.
You have your opinion and I have mine.
Melo/CP3/Rose/Harden are allstars in my mind, like I said Lebron/Durant are once a generation type talents they will go down as top 10 players alltime when they are done playing, you cant say the same for those other guys.
Just my personal opinion, but I think you have your classifications off. Lebron/Durant will be Hall of Fame Type players being two of the best all time. These other players are franchise players... players you build your team around.
Also it is flawed to use team success to categorize and individual players as franchise/all-star. Just look how players go from one team who is garbage and then to another better team and have success. It doesn't mean that players talent changed or elevated, just that they had a better team. That's like saying Dan Marion wasn't a franchise player... Steve Nash MVP is not a franchise player, Derrick Rose is not a franchise player.