Revis used to be a great corner. Right now he is coming off injury and has to prove he still has it not the other way around. And your McCoy argument makes little sense. Saying they would be bad without him doesn't make him great it speaks to a lack of depth. And if it he is better against the run than Edwards then why did Edwards have almost twice as many tackles. And if everyone passed more against the bucks then why did Edwards get more sacks with little help in the middle. I am not arguing that Edwards should be up there simply that McCoy is overrated and had a mediocre year and others deserve that spot.
Again, until proven otherwise, Revis is the best corner in the NFL.
Ummm, no it's not. You're easily swayed by numbers but accumulating more tackles than another player doesn't mean 'superiority'. Kevin Williams had a 33 tackle season, and he was still a dominant DT that very season. Now McCoy wasn't that impactful but he was paramount to The Bucs' rushing defense in 2012, especially since Tampa lacks a linebacking core.